Saturday, 21 November 2026

Cuttings: September 2026

‘If you build something vastly smarter than you, it better be on your side’: can we stop AI from deceiving us? – article by Snigdha Poonam in The Guardian. ”Large language models (LLMs) go through three fundamental stages of training. The first is pre-training, where a model absorbs vast archives of written text – books, websites, messageboards etc – as well as videos and other forms of data about the human world. The model repeatedly makes predictions and compares them with the “correct” answers until it can reliably figure out broad patterns in how people speak, write and behave.… Then comes fine-tuning, when a pre-trained model learns to apply the broad knowledge it has gained through smaller, targeted datasets…. The third fundamental stage of training is ‘reinforcement learning with human feedback‘, or RLHF. Here the algorithm meets real-life humans: evaluators who test how a model behaves in a wide range of situations and rate its output.… If pre-training is learning how to cook, and fine-tuning is learning specific recipes, then RLHF is like diners tasting those dishes and giving feedback. To receive positive feedback, the model must perform its tasks while following ‘human values‘, a broad set of principles intended to shape it in the mould of a considerate person. Through this iterative process, the models, in principle, learn to avoid anything that is considered undesirable, such as harmful instructions, bias and lying. The experts I spoke to agreed that RLHF helps explain why AIs deceive. Thanks to this process, Bengio said, earning positive feedback from humans becomes an ‘implicit goal‘ for AI models. But as we know from our own lives, delivering true but unwelcome information may not earn positive feedback. By contrast, telling a person what they want to hear, even if it is untrue, is an effective short-term way to win that person’s favour. ‘Fundamentally,‘ Bengio told me, ‘lying and deception are rational behaviours to achieve many goals. This is why humans do it. And this is why the AIs do it now.’”

The Future Starts With Us by Gordon Brown: the ex-PM’s recipe for beating populism – review by Gaby Hinsliff in The Guardian. “What is new for Brown … is that this book is preoccupied less with economics than with the argument that collapsing civic ties – the fact that we’re less likely now than a generation ago to be part of a club, trade union, church or community group – have helped undermine ’the very idea that we are all in this together, that there are common causes worth fighting for’. What could be just another nostalgic, even reactionary, argument for a bygone age when everyone knew their neighbours is tempered by Brown’s willingness to acknowledge that much of this togetherness was built on the unpaid labour of women stuck at home. But it’s also brought up to date by his argument that this fraying of social bonds – especially in towns fallen on hard times, now leaning towards populist politicians – is actively connected to fragmentation and the retreat from multilateralism on the world stage. It’s time, he argues, to stop treating breakdown at home and breakup abroad as separate phenomena. Beating populism obviously means tackling the economic grievances – the disappearing jobs and hollowed-out high streets – on which it feeds in post-industrial communities across the US and Europe. Yet the general rolling chaos that populists tend to unleash on the world stage makes it actively harder for everyone else to build stable and prosperous economies, creating a vicious circle of decline. Brown’s answer is to build a virtuous circle instead, from the ground up. Strengthening civic ties should make people feel less lonely, more secure and trusting, and thus hopefully more relaxed about their governments acting generously and collaboratively at an international level. That, of course, is key to tackling everything from the climate crisis, to global poverty, to forming the kind of alliances with other middle-ranking powers that might prevent a country like the UK being totally steamrollered in a standoff between the US and China. At least, that’s the theory.“

Gloria Steinem personified America’s feminist movement – article by Moira Donegan in The Guardian. “Experience has a way of radicalizing women about their own gendered condition. Steinem attended Smith, and her education opened up previously unhoped for possibilities. En route to a postgraduate fellowship in India in 1957, when she was in her early 20s, she had an illegal abortion in London. Later, in 1969, while she was working as a journalist for New York magazine, she attended an ‘abortion speak-out‘ put on by a group of radical women from the emergent fringe of what was then called the Women’s Liberation movement.… The woman who walked out would become one of the most successful and visible faces of the second wave, a figurehead who came to personify the feminist movement itself. The former journalist, keenly aware of both the dynamics of mass media and of the potential uses of her own willowy good looks, deployed stardom and glamour in the service of the feminist cause. She was not the first famous feminist, but she might be said to have been the first famous feminist of the celebrity era, forging a public persona halfway between Madonna and Joan of Arc. Her magazine Ms, launched in 1972, brought the women’s liberation movement, once largely confined to the hip downtowns of major cities such as New York and Chicago, to newsstands across America. But Steinem’s work was not exclusive to the media: she also campaigned relentlessly, and sometimes successfully, to make the feminist movement a power player within the Democratic party, brokering her own support in exchange for policy commitments from candidates.“

An Unexpected Life by Gloria Steinem: a fitting tribute to a feminist icon – review by Emma Brockes in The Guardian. "An Unexpected Life is a follow-up of sorts to My Life on the Road, the activist’s memoir of a decade ago, and as the tributes [following her death] pour in, the book offers us an opportunity to go back over Steinem’s hardscrabble origins in Toledo, Ohio, and the roots of her activism. This is where it all happened, the formation of a woman who would come to define second wave feminism by combining a tough-as-they-come stance with something that looked a lot like serenity. Reading the first half of the book, one is reminded of Steinem’s original power and the improbability and iconoclasm of her journey, in which a childhood governed by poverty and dysfunction turned into a lifelong mission to resist the narrow templates laid out for her.... What I found interesting in the book were Steinem’s asides about the cost of pursuing the life she chose. 'Though I managed to support myself,' she writes, 'I didn’t save money until I was past fifty. I was sure that I’d end up as a bag lady, like women I saw sleeping in subway stations. I used to handle that fear by thinking, It’s a life like any other. I’ll organize the other bag ladies.'.. Steinem is the real thing, of course; she was never in it for the money. She makes a strong case that she wasn’t in it for the attention, either, although, as a talented speaker and organiser, she drew on great reserves of magnetism that over the years caused her a lot of problems with jealousy from within the movement, and condescension from without. Right until the end, Steinem was stewarding large groups of women – famous and otherwise – at 'talking circles' in her house and putting herself at the centre of a conversation she had in some ways begun.... She writes powerfully about women who made different, unhappier choices under pain of social death: 'I remember one woman, married to a socially acceptable man much older than she, who explained, "After he dies, I’ll be free." The cost of freedom seemed to mean she was able to live only in the future.' It is useful to be reminded of how bad things were so very recently.... As we enter the post-Steinem era – a statement that seems outlandish, given the length and ardour of her service – it’s a pleasure, simply, to spend time in her company, and her role as an elder is one she takes seriously... 'My role as an older person is to remind us how far we have come, and with age comes the responsibility to keep learning.... Now even my jeans are much older than many people I work with.' We should all be so lucky; what a life.“

‘If he can make money in a tyranny, that’s fine by him’: Francis Fukuyama on Trump, democracy – and changing his mind – interview by Jonathan Freedland in The Guardian, on the publication of his book In the Realm of the Last Man. "Thanks to that simple, memorable phrase – 'the end of history' – people assumed that Fukuyama was arguing that, with the cold war winding down and the Berlin Wall about to fall, human conflict, even human events, were drawing to a close. That all the big arguments had been settled, there would be no more war, and the entire world was about to live under US-style liberal democracy. As he puts it in his new book, In the Realm of the Last Man, it was taken to be an expression of 'naive liberal triumphalism, and I have been asked several times a week over the past three decades whether I wished to recant my argument. I have written thousands of words and given dozens of interviews seeking to answer this question.' Indeed, he tells me, that was 'one of the reasons for writing the memoir: to finally get down in a very clear way what I was intending and the ways I was wrong, and the ways I believe I’m still right.' The book makes clear his argument was a subtle one, drawn from Hegelian thought and inspired by an earlier interpreter of Hegel, Alexandre Kojève, from whom Fukuyama borrowed that all-important title. According to Kojève, the end of history was the moment when a principle or set of ideas emerged that could not be bettered, in terms of their ability to satisfy the human beings who lived in a system shaped by them.... This was the nature of the argument Fukuyama was making for 1989. Not that liberal democracy was perfect or that it had been achieved everywhere and that all conflict was over. But rather that the evidence had become compelling that there was no better guiding principle or system. And Fukuyama still maintains that view.... He ... accepts that the current consensus on liberal democracy is far from universal, and that the 'liberal' part of that idea – the belief in constraints and checks on elected power – is especially vulnerable. He writes that is in part because support for those constraints has often been contingent on a collective memory of how dangerous the world can become without them. A younger generation who have known only peace and prosperity, and for whom the tyrannies of the mid-20th century are ancient history, will only be dimly aware of the perils of unrestrained, illiberal rule. But surely Donald Trump, born just one year after the defeat of nazism, is living proof that proximity to that dark history hardly entails respect for the guardrails imposed by liberal democracy? How do we explain the US president’s disregard for that danger? 'You know, that is one of the great psychological questions that future historians are going to have to answer. He has had this weird attraction not just to the current Russia and Vladimir Putin but, all the way back in the 1980s, he visited Moscow. He took out these full-page ads attacking Nato way back then, when we were still in the middle of the cold war. I mean, it somehow has to do with his lack of any kind of moral compass beyond his own self-interest. He basically worries about whether he can make money, and if you can make money in a tyranny, that’s fine with him.' ... As Fukuyama writes now: 'The being who emerges at the end of history is typically someone stripped of struggle, risk and ambition, someone whom the philosopher Nietzsche labeled the "Last Man". We have been living in the realm of the Last Man for some time now.' Once this notion is unpacked, even those who dispute Fukuyama’s reading of 1989 will concede that he had an uncanny inkling of what was to come. For what he was anticipating was that liberal democratic societies might prove adept at delivering stability and relative material comfort, but that would still leave something profound missing. He cites Socrates’ notion of thymos, or spiritedness: that part of the soul which desires the respect or esteem of other human beings. The last man might have his basic economic needs met, but he would become angry if he believed he was not receiving the recognition that was his due. It amounts to the simple craving for one’s equal dignity to be respected."

The Bayeux tapestry: a stupefying, thrilling, horrifying masterpiece that shakes the earth – review by Jonathan Jones in The Guardian. "It should not work. It should not even exist. Nothing about the Bayeux tapestry makes sense according to any norms of art: its creators couldn’t do proper portraits or pictorial depth or landscapes or any of the sophisticated things we associate with timeless masterpieces. When they depict a church, they have to write what it is: Ecclesia. But these artists – or who knows, perhaps she was a single artist – created something so stupefying and delightful, so abundant in visual thrills, horrors and humour, it beats almost everything else ever painted or carved – let alone embroidered on a strip of linen.... This is pacy art: it hurtles along. In fact, that’s how it embraces you. Your heart pounds with a sense of doom and destiny. This is, you realise, the greatest battle in art.... When hell is finally unleashed, the Norman cavalry pound with such force you can almost hear hooves shake the earth. Norman archers fire continuous volleys that send arrow shafts straight into Saxon bodies. Meanwhile, the Saxons stand manfully in hauberks with their axes and take it. They give it, too, to the point that William seems for a moment to be losing the day, horses tipping over, knights falling. It’s in such images that the Bayeux tapestry transcends everything you could reasonably expect of a medieval artwork. The scene where the Norman cavalry seems to falter is simultaneously realistic and nightmarish. One horse is completely upended, its face to the earth, rear legs in the sky. Another tips over as its rider slides forward, his armoured body suddenly a helpless rag.... In both the borders and central strip, the Bayeux tapestry always set its action in a wider world, and even, when it shows the comet, a larger cosmos. As the armoured elite go to war, peasants plough and sow the fields. They are portrayed in distracting, vibrant detail and this workaday scene as the battle approaches is pointed and poignant: whoever wins, whoever rules England, country people will still work the soil. That same sudden cutaway from the rulers’ perspective happens when a woman and her child watch the Normans set their house on fire. But what you can see here, close to the stitches in such good light, is that one of the men torching the house also seems sad and conflicted. It’s that honesty that makes this not just a fascinating medieval relic but a universal depiction of the madness that is war. If the violence is stunningly real, so are its consequences."

‘Capitalism is dying’: in Luton, these former car workers have a moral tale for our times – article by Aditya Chakrabortty in The Guardian. "After everything, why would anyone still back Nigel Farage? In some of the comments below my piece last week about Reform UK, I spot the usual answers: Farage’s supporters are dim, racist, deplorable. Yet away from Westminster and the news cycle, Reform voters are being manufactured – not with headlines or crypto funds but through the failure of institutions they once trusted to protect them. To see what I mean, leave SW1 and go 40 miles up the road, to Luton.... Vauxhall came to Luton not long after the death of Queen Victoria; it helped build the town and gave it an economy and an identity. At its peak in 1971, the company directly employed 37,000 staff in Britain, mostly in Luton. Now it is leaving.... The ex-Vauxhall workers talking to me are nothing to do with the rightward exploitation. But since their factory’s closure, they have seen fellow union members switch in droves from voting for Keir Starmer in 2024 to backing Farage. It’s not just Labour; their disgust is at a society they feel has let them and their families go under... See this from a Luton worker’s point of view. The company to whom you’ve given half your life has first castigated you for not being as cheap as your Turkish counterparts, then upped and left. The union to whom you pay your subs wasn’t able to stop it going. Also impotent was the Labour government you voted for – again. Luton lost its car plant under Tony Blair, it lost its van plant under Starmer. Now you’re out of work, and – in the case of Mohammed Hussain, sitting next to me – you’ve just bought a house with a hefty mortgage. More than a year later, he’s still out of work.... In the late 1960s, a group of sociologists visited then booming Luton, interviewing workers at Vauxhall and elsewhere for a renowned series of books, titled The Affluent Worker. Its central question was: when the working classes get middle-class salaries and mod cons, what happens to their class identity? Sixty years later, Britain is running the experiment in reverse, driving working-class families into deprivation and smashing up their communities. The results are not yet in, but they look bad."

Losing a parent is a bewildering, lonely experience. Here are the things I wish I had known before – article by Gaby Hinsliff in The Guardian. "Fiercely independent at 84, my mother dreaded going into a home. So when she was given less than three months to live, my sister and I promised to nurse her at home, despite having no real plan for managing that alongside jobs and teenage children, beyond somehow basically winging it. Have a baby and the world falls over itself to offer advice. But losing a parent remains a private, bewildering, lonely affair. Here, then, are a few things I wish I’d known at the beginning of summer, in case – like [her now empty hospital bed, awaiting collection] – another family can use them. That care for the dying will trigger the instant muscle memory of caring for small children, if you had them: the same broken nights, same constant vigilance, same exhaustion after a day in which you can’t name a single thing you actually did, and the same unmistakable feeling of love tinged with occasional rage.... That there are moments of unspeakably black humour to be found even in dying, if you’re that kind of family. That there are times when your role is to argue with their doctors, and times for shutting up and listening, and you may never be wholly certain which is which. That if an old person in beady possession of all their marbles goes seemingly mad overnight, test for an underlying infection causing delirium. Antibiotics work miracles. That you should keep the bad photographs, because afterwards they’re the ones you invariably want to look at: anything where the kids were scowling, the haircuts sorely regrettable, the beach day rained off. It’s the life actually lived, not the one curated for Instagram, that you miss. That death can trigger an overwhelming urge to put one’s house in order in ways that make sense to the dying, but absolutely nobody else. (My mother had to be dissuaded from getting the sitting room repainted; a friend’s father insisted on alphabetising his CDs.) Within reason, don’t fight it. Like the manic nesting phase of late pregnancy, it’s all part of the process. That if you find old letters, you should read them only when feeling resilient. Your parents had lives before you existed and secrets they may not have shared. That death itself is different for everyone, but that even the most peaceful kind looked to me like a form of work. The best way I can describe it is like a reverse childbirth: you can comfort the person going through it, but you cannot be in it with them. That it wasn’t nearly as frightening as that may sound. That grief doesn’t always wait for death. Dementia meant I lost my father in some ways years before he died, and a wise friend said that nursing my mother might feel, in retrospect, like starting to work through bereavement in advance. She wasn’t wrong. That adrenaline may power you through initially, and kindness may undo you. And lastly, what I think my mother would have wanted me to say: that if this is something you have yet to face, don’t be afraid. But if you’re already there and struggling, then you are nowhere near as alone as you think."

I’m a father of three who studies the impact of artificial intelligence: this is what parents need to know about AI – article by Daniel Susskind in The Guardian, based on his book What Should My Children Do? "Today, we are floundering. Teachers worry that the way they teach no longer seems to work. Parents, watching their children use AI to solve problems and answer questions, wonder what they really know. Employers doubt whether traditional educational achievements, awarded in time-honoured ways – coursework, exams, assessments – are still a useful guide to what young people can do. Yet reacting to these new technologies by putting barriers up, as many instinctively want to do – banning, admonishing, punishing – just cannot be right. To begin with, this is the water in which the next generation will swim: we are letting them down if we prepare them for the world that we grew up in, not the one they will actually inhabit.... Forget future-proofing skills. A big part of the challenge of AI is that our traditional response to technological disruption in the working world – the idea of 'future-proofing' people – no longer works. In 2013, the then prime minister David Cameron announced that England would become the first place in the world where all children in primary and secondary schools would learn to code.... Fast-forward to today. What does it turn out that the latest AI systems, such as ChatGPT and Claude, are best at doing? Writing code.... The truth is that we know only two things about what lies ahead. One is that it will be full of technologies that are far more capable than today. And the other is that we know little else. But rather than attempting to resolve this uncertainty, we have to accept it and instead ask a different question: how do we prepare the next generation to flourish in a future that we actually know surprisingly little about? Get back to basics.... Since 2009, literacy and numeracy have been falling among young people around the world... Given the uncertainty that we face about the future, these trends are a disaster.... To begin with, while it might be hard to say precisely which more advanced skills will turn out to be most valuable in the future – creativity, judgment, something else – they will rely in some way on these basic skills.... What’s more, AI systems are far from flawless.... That means we must use AI critically, not blindly... With both those reasons in mind, we should be focusing intensely on teaching literacy and numeracy, even if AI does them better, as it increasingly seems to do....Teach both, test both. The [1982] Cockcroft Report .. may turn out to be the most important document written for thinking about the future of education, because of its response to the electronic calculator... Cockcroft was realistic: 'all candidates', he expected, 'will have access to a calculator by 1985'. And his proposal was revolutionary: overhauling mathematics education by splitting it into two parts, spending part of the time teaching students to use a calculator and the rest of the time learning to cope without one – and crucially, testing both. It caught on. Learning maths without and with a calculator is now the gold standard around the world, the former nurturing the basics and the latter applying them to more fiendish problems. We should also be realistic and revolutionary, adopting this tried-and-tested principle – what I call 'teach both, test both' – for AI now. Every subject, from history to English literature, should be divided in two: teach students to use AI in one part, teach students to flourish without it in the other – and, crucially, examine both.... Focus on problems, not the job. I am not surprised that students have been booing tech titans during recent US graduation ceremonies... There is so much advice I would want to give them, worried at the start of their careers. But one of the most important bits is to choose a profession because the problem interests you, not the job. Bluntly, if you go into medicine because you like the look of doctors on House, or law because of Suits, or marketing because of Mad Men, then you are going to be disappointed. These jobs are soon going to look very different. But the problems themselves – improving health outcomes, providing legal advice, selling products? They are not going away. It is the way we solve them, and the skills required to do so, that will look very different."

Hawking by Graham Farmelo: the dark side of genius – review by Philip Ball in The Guardian. "In this new biography, veteran science writer Graham Farmelo [provides] a comprehensive and accessible portrait of a brilliant scientist and an extraordinarily determined man who also possessed deep personal flaws to which the scientific community and the public mostly turned a blind eye. The uncomfortable but unavoidable truth is that Hawking’s overweening ambition and self-promotion, his repeated failure to acknowledge the work of others, his sexism and controlling behaviour were largely ignored because of his disability. I think it is indeed going to take us years to process that.... I’m not alone in thinking Hawking’s work on black-hole thermodynamics and the discovery of Hawking radiation were worthy of a Nobel prize. (Hawking became obsessed to an unseemly degree with getting one.) But let’s keep it in proportion. Anyone who compares Hawking to Einstein knows nothing about Einstein or physics. Einstein made wide-ranging contributions to the discipline, but Hawking’s expertise was narrow and his forays outside it were sometimes embarrassing. Even in the closely related field of particle physics he said things that were, as Peter Higgs (of Higgs boson fame) said, 'total crap'.... Which brings us to the problematic stuff. While professional colleagues mostly spoke about Hawking with reverence and affection, it is often those closest to him who speak of another side. His father, Frank, worried that the teenaged Stephen 'was developing into a selfish character … like a small boy who took everything but gave little in return'.... His unsparing ridicule of his first wife Jane’s religious beliefs contributed to their marital tensions, and the sacrifices she made often went unremarked by him. The pressure of going from lover to carer would never have been easy, but Hawking’s 'authoritarian' demands and indifference to Jane’s interests added to her isolation.... Sometimes the indulgence gets creepy. Who else’s Marilyn Monroe obsession would be pampered by hiring a lookalike to croon 'I want to be loved by you' to him in a 'whispery voice' on his birthday?... Hawking was scandalously bad at giving due scientific credit to others, a trait evident from the outset when he failed to indicate his debt to Penrose. Worse was his treatment of physicist Jacob Bekenstein, whose idea about the connection between the area and the entropy of a black hole he mercilessly derided before discovering for himself that Bekenstein was right – and then essentially claiming the idea as his own, which Farmelo says 'disappointed some of Stephen’s friends'. Hawking could clearly be a supportive and kind adviser to his own students, but when one discovered an argument for why Hawking was wrong about a conjecture concerning black holes, he tried to get him dismissed from the Cambridge PhD programme. Some of his colleagues, Farmelo says, 'believed that Stephen’s talks were "all about him" and that he rarely gave much public credit to his peers'. Farmelo suspects they rarely grumbled because 'such comments would have been interpreted as mean-spirited'. But mean-spiritedness rarely deters academics; what he surely means is mean-spirited about a scientist with a disability. And there’s the problem. If we were to start finally treating Hawking as we do any other scientist, it would be a positive step for disability in science (which is still poorly accommodated). The effect on Hawking’s legacy is another matter."

‘I suggested maybe a lighter touch’: William Shatner on Star Trek at 60 – article by David Smith in The Guardian. “Born in the idealism of the 1960s, the show offered a utopian vision of the future in which humanity sought to explore rather than conquer. Diversity, empathy and reason had triumphed over tribalism, superstition and greed. Big government and big tech were liberators from scarcity and inequality.… But six decades on, the Enterprise is encountering some cosmic turbulence. Donald Trump’s America is convulsed by polarisation, culture wars and the retreat of liberal democracy, along with anxiety over artificial intelligence and climate catastrophe. Paramount, merged with Skydance Media for $8bn, promptly cancelled the latest Star Trek series amid claims that it was too ‘woke’. The rightwing complainers yearn for a return to the days of Iowa-born Captain Kirk, who fits their conceit of an all-American hero, even though Shatner is Canadian. When he was hired in 1965 after NBC rejected Jeffrey Hunter’s dour pilot performance as Captain Pike, he brought an athletic, theatrical charisma that lifted the cerebral storytelling. ‘I saw the film and I thought it was really interesting, a little ponderous,’ Shatner, a sprightly 95, recalls of the original pilot.... ‘So I suggested maybe a lighter touch, and we made another pilot and it sold.’… Star Trek is still pushing boundaries, much to the chagrin of unlikely fan Stephen Miller, the deputy White House chief of staff and driver of Trump’s extremist immigration policy. In January Miller cited a social media account called End Wokeness that mocked the newest Star Trek series, Starfleet Academy, as 'Beyond parody'.… Shatner laughs at the idea of White House aides spending their days picking holes in Star Trek…. He rejects Miller’s notion that Star Trek’s inclusiveness has gone too far.… ’Where should I have stopped? And by the way, what is “woke”?’… Mark Altman, co-author of The Fifty-Year Mission and director of a new documentary, The 60-Year Mission, says via Zoom from Los Angeles: “ [Roddenberry and writing partner Gene Coon’s] approach to Star Trek was they had lost a lot of friends and had seen war up close and they didn’t romanticise it. They knew the cost of war. They weren’t changing the name of the Department of Defense to the Department of War. They loathed war. That’s something I find shocking, these deeply conservative fans like Stephen Miller say, “I’m a huge fan of Star Trek.“ How is that possible? Did they miss the memo that in reality, Star Trek abhorred war, and it always said that talking is the way to resolve conflict?’”… Altman regards Kirk as an analogue for John F Kennedy, the young president who had pledged to reach the moon before the decade was out. “The final frontier is the New Frontier. Kirk is very much a Kennedy-esque liberal. He’s liberal on social issues but more hard-nosed on defence.…
But if you look at The Next Generation, it’s a very George HW Bush vision: consensus-building, a thousand points of light…. Deep Space Nine was heavily rewritten in the aftermath of the Los Angeles riots and the beating of Rodney King. It was all about rebuilding and asking, can’t we all just get along?… When you’re on a starship and everything’s great, it’s easy to be a saint in paradise. But on a station, there’s more of a struggle and more conflict.‘”

‘A completely unique opportunity’: the secretive process that will decide the BBC’s future – article by Barbara Speed in The Guardian. “Charter renewal is partly an exercise in predicting the future: in deciding what Britain and the media landscape will look like in a decade, and how the BBC must transform accordingly. This is why it is so difficult, and so fraught. The charter is the only way that the BBC’s purpose, funding model or governance can be drastically changed. It is through charter renewals that the BBC built Britain’s television infrastructure, launched its first website and built a streaming platform, the iPlayer, while Netflix was still sending out DVDs through the post. The risk of failing to meet the moment bedevils every charter renewal. Debates about the BBC are so familiar that they have become a kind of white noise: whether it is secretly right or leftwing; whether it contributed to Brexit or sought to undermine it; whether its stars are paid too much, and so on. But to look at the history of charter renewal is to see that the real existential threats it faces are never the stuff of fleeting scandals or culture wars. In 2026, what is really threatening the BBC are the much larger tides of changing technology and changing habits. Year on year, fewer and fewer people are using the BBC, and fewer and fewer people are paying for it. Hundreds of millions of pounds in cuts are under way to balance the books. This charter renewal is its only chance to turn back those tides.… From the huge array of opinions that swirl around the BBC, however, it is possible to discern three broad schools of thought. The first camp, the custodians, frames the corporation as a vital fortress, to be defended in its current form, at all costs. In this view, the BBC’s primacy in British life is assumed and its founding principles of independence from government and universality are sacrosanct.… The second camp, the shrinkers, views the BBC as one media company among many – one granted unfair advantages. In the past, it was this camp that argued successfully against the BBC’s monopoly first on radio, and then on television. These days, they rail against successful programmes such as The Traitors and Strictly Come Dancing, which, they say, could be made by commercial rivals. The shrinkers argue that the BBC should stick to its USP – the public service meat and potatoes of current affairs and children’s programming.… A third camp – let’s call them the engineers – believes the argument between the shrinkers and the custodians misses the point entirely. The BBC was founded to both produce radio programmes and to run the wireless network for the public good. That logic, the engineers say, should now be applied to digital media.… In an era of streamers, AI and social media platforms, the engineers believe the BBC should be building its own platforms or algorithms, so as to be less reliant on US billionaires, setting up safe social media sites for the under-16s, or offering free internet access for public service content. If it doesn’t, then those without broadband will lose access to BBC channels when terrestrial is switched off, which could be as soon as 2034. Pat Younge, a former BBC chief creative officer and now chair of the campaigning organisation British Broadcasting Challenge, told me: ‘The biggest threat when Donald Trump said he might sue the BBC wasn’t that he would sue – it was that he would get Jeff Bezos to withdraw Amazon Web Services from them, at which point iPlayer collapses.”

Mistakes, mistrust and misdirection: 25 years after 9/11, its dark legacy continues to unfold – article by David Smith in The Guardian. “America … has struggled to carry the weight of the worst terrorist attack in its history.… At first the loss brought out America’s better angels. Firefighters and first responders displayed inspiring courage. Ordinary citizens queued to donate blood. The nation came together as rarely before and received global sympathy, with Russia pledging support, Iran holding candlelight vigils and Nato invoking Article 5 for the first and only time in its history. Bush visited Ground Zero in New York and, wielding a megaphone, declared that ’the people who knocked these buildings down will hear all of us soon.’ They did. The US invaded Afghanistan to destroy al-Qaida and topple its Taliban protectors, a war that would drag on for a record 20 years only for the Taliban to return. Bush then attacked Iraq on the false premise that Saddam Hussein possessed weapons of mass destruction, at a cost of hundreds of thousands of lives. The global war on terror expanded into a sprawling enterprise of military intervention, intelligence operations, detention and interrogation. Some suspects were tortured, including through waterboarding at CIA ’black sites’. A quarter of a century later, 100 million Americans are too young to remember 9/11 and only from this vantage point, perhaps, can the consequences be seen clearly. Historians and policy experts interviewed by the Guardian suggest that the reaction to 9/11 was a profound strategic miscalculation that distracted the US from the rise of China and sowed the seeds of its own decline…. If the terrorist’s success is measured by the magnitude of the self-inflicted wounds they provoke from their target, Bin Laden’s legacy is a slow, autoimmune decay within the US, it may have exceeded his darkest fantasies.”

Taipei Story by Rebecca F Kuang: the torture and hilarity of learning Chinese – review by Kit Fan in The Guardian. "What is Taiwan? A former Japanese colony? A centre of the semiconductor industry? A democracy overseen by American imperialism? China’s next military target? An island of Austronesian Indigenous tribes? Is Taipei a cultural emblem of Taiwan, or just another booming global capital out of touch with the rest of the country? What stories will Lily Chen, an American Chinese student at Yale and Rebecca F Kuang’s funny and deadpan protagonist in Taipei Story, discover in this melting pot while spending 10 weeks learning Mandarin?... Centring on a tough Mandarin language school, Taipei Story explores the torture, hilarity and pretension of learning a second language, but here Kuang also offers a heartfelt journey of self-discovery and family wounds. Lily sets a clear boundary early on: 'I wanted to become Chinese here, on my own terms.' Her classmates soon spot that 'Lily is very insecure about her Chineseness'. Kuang renders the toxic dynamics and loneliness of foreign students with tact and heart. But what takes the novel beyond the usual campus relationship drama is Kuang’s meticulous, closeup account of Lily’s determination to learn Mandarin.... Lily is a captivating character; she mocks herself when she feels taken in, as though authenticity derives from the art of counterfeiting. To master Mandarin, she dutifully immerses herself in Taiwanese culture, visiting night markets, eating local food and living in a grotty private apartment rather than university accommodation. In her mission of 'trying to blend in', she discovers the composite layers of Taiwan’s history, sees the ghosts of China, Japan and America everywhere, and finds 'no framework for making sense of' anything."

End Times Fascism by Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor: the fightback starts here – review by Daniel Trilling in The Guardian. “'The most powerful people in the world are preparing for the end of the world, an end they themselves are frenetically accelerating,' Klein and Taylor write, describing a loose alliance of three principal factions rooted in US political and business elites. First are the religious fanatics who see each new disaster as a welcome sign we are entering the end of days, but find common ground with secular demagogues who promise a glorious, prosperous future on the ruins of our present.... Next are the new tech barons, who preach that only the AI 'arms race', as Klein and Taylor put it, can save humanity – even as its demand for water and electricity scorches the planet – while they themselves dream of sitting out societal breakdown in remote, fortified enclaves. Last come the political entrepreneurs who transform visions of disaster into votes by promising to turn their nations into bunkered garrison states. Migration draws most of the attention, but you can also see this logic at work in an increasingly aggressive global scramble for natural resources: 'supersized prepping at the level of the nation-state', in Klein and Taylor’s words. This is nothing less than a revival of fascism, the authors argue... In their definition, [fascism] is a recurring tendency among elites that manifests when capitalism no longer works the way they would like it to, and they feel their positions are threatened.... Klein and Taylor draw particular inspiration from Zohran Mamdani, whose successful run for the New York mayoralty showed it was possible to build a winning coalition by focusing on people’s material concerns – and by celebrating difference rather than trying to deny or apologise for it. They also point to other, creative forms of resistance in the US and elsewhere as the seeds of a new politics 'rooted in an expansive, open-armed sense of neighbourliness' that can counter the right’s dystopian visions of the future.... it does raise questions about where the best lessons can be learned. Is the rest of the world expected to take its cue from American progressives? Or is there more we could discover, say, in parts of the world where reactionary, authoritarian politics has prevailed for longer – and where people might have developed longer-term strategies?"

Naomi Klein: ‘Extreme wealth has a deranging effect. It turns you into a supremacist’ – interview by Zoe Williams in The Guardian. "'I think we understand that wealth compounds, right? Certainly rich people understand that wealth compounds,' Klein [says]... 'But I don’t feel like we spend a lot of time really thinking about the implications of what it means for that much wealth to be compounded, and what that does psychologically. Part of the new shamelessness we’re seeing is just what happens when this amount of financial, mediagenic, technological and military weaponry is concentrated in the hands of this very small, unaccountable group of people. They stop trying to seduce us in any way.'... This book started as an article in the Guardian, 'which went totally viral,' Klein says. 'Astra [Taylor] and I knew there was a lot more reporting to do, but on a personal level, did we want to spend the next year in the minds of these people, in these cultures? Then Astra said, "I’m down the rabbit hole, I’m gonna be listening to these guys anyway. So I may as well feel like I’m doing something about it." This is the reason it’s the first book I’ve co-written. When you go to dark, scary places, it’s nice to bring a friend.' ... In the book, Klein and Taylor introduce us to the religious fundamentalists, Christian Zionists and Christian Nationalists in the US, readying themselves for the second coming. Describing a 'bunkered state', the authors connect climate-related disasters, a rabid anti-immigrant standing army in the form of ICE and a politics built on false promises and misinformation to depict a febrile, riven society that doesn’t know what to believe. But the truly terrifying bit is the bridging section, on tech billionaires. The super-rich have apocalypse fantasies of their own, built not on faith or ideology but on a calm and rational evaluation of how best to maintain their position; they would genuinely rather reign in hell than share in heaven. And they have all the money to make sure they get there... The neoliberal age – for brevity let’s call it the period between the end of the cold war and Covid – was 'capitalism lying on the couch in its underwear, going "what are you gonna do, leave me?" In the cold war, a little competition went a long way – after the collapse of the Soviet Union, that competition is lost, capitalism stopped trying.' But there was a vulnerability to being super-rich in those days, because whether you’d come by your wealth through privatisation politics in the US or Europe, or by hastier, more kleptocratic means in ex-communist states, it was plainly public wealth that you’d captured. 'So they would stage these seduction rituals, whether it was at Davos or Aspen, or at Ted, or the Clinton Global Initiative. They’d say, "We are going to cure the sick, and we are going to fund your schools in this new and exciting way, don’t worry about us. Don’t be afraid of our wealth. This is actually a new way of redistributing for the public good."' Many people, Klein at their vanguard, pointed out that it smelled like a scam. But while we were having that discussion, the wealth agenda moved on.... There’s a new goading quality to the talking points of the super-rich – explicit eugenicism and Islamophobia, raw delight in the prospect of AI wiping out our jobs. It almost feels as though they’re daring us to rebel, just so that they can prove that rebellion is fruitless. On that, though, Klein would disagree. It is not beyond our collective means to build a wealth disarmament movement, or a tech disarmament movement."

Faster! Louder! Brighter! How the attention economy overwhelmed children’s TV – article by Natalia Kucirkova in The Guardian. "Children’s media is usually judged by its content and quality: how many minutes watched and whether it was educational, age-appropriate, diverse, prosocial, commercial and safe.... But we have been missing a bigger design feature that may be just as consequential: the time a medium gives a child to make meaning. A programme or app can contain good lessons and still move too quickly for those lessons to settle.... Across [different] media, the important question is whether the pace suits the experience that the narrative claims to support. Does it give children time to follow a story, grasp a concept, identify with a character, regulate emotion or share attention with another person? Or does it continually hurry them toward the next cue, the next reward, the next burst of stimulation? When media moves too quickly, the layers of experience collapse into one another. A child may laugh at someone slipping on a banana peel but imitate only the visible silliness, missing the anticipation and reversal that make the joke work. A character may comfort a friend, but if the scene moves on too quickly, the child has little time to recognise the repair, or imagine doing the same in the kindergarten room. To develop empathy in the early years, a child must notice that another person feels something different. That small act of crossing over takes time.... [But] spend five minutes watching what many young children watch, and you will see how fast, loud and bright everything on the screen has become. It does not matter whether the child is watching on a smartphone in the car or on a TV at home. The screen has inherited the adult logic of media design. That logic is, for the most part, the logic of the attention economy. It overwhelms and overshouts, making it easier for the screen to steer the viewer.... Evaluating children’s popular media taught me that pace is a revealing measure of quality but also a proxy for a deeper question about the child’s agency, their own sense of self. The real distinction is whether a medium leaves room for the child’s own attention or continually redirects it. When every pause is filled, every uncertainty immediately resolved and every wandering thought pulled back by a brighter cue, waiting and reflection can begin to feel intolerable. The child learns to reach for the next stimulus before the previous one has had time to settle. To give space for a child’s attention to drift inward, to reflect, is therefore to leave room for the child’s inner life. Slow media changes the relation between screen and child by saying: you may arrive at your own pace."

Previously unseen drawings by Moomins author Tove Jansson to go on show in London - article by Dalya Alberge in The Guardian. "Billed as the UK’s first exhibition to focus on Jansson’s illustrations, ['Tove Jansson and her Families' at the Quentin Blake Centre for Illustration] will feature sketches, photographs and films, as well as her correspondence with those closest to her and fans of all ages. The displays will include original art from her first published book, The Moomins and the Great Flood, in which she presented a world 'where everything was natural and benign – and possible', in a story about Moomintroll’s search, with Moominmamma, for their missing Moominpappa and how they found their way to the magical Moominvalley.... Sophia Jansson, Tove’s niece, told the Guardian: 'She had this very special skill to harness themes that touch the reader … on a universal and a personal level – and then disguise them in these stories, so that we think we’re reading about Moomins in Moominvalley and, when you finish the book, you realise that you’re actually reading about "us", about humans and how we interact and all our peculiarities.'"

England ’Til I Die: a chilling portrait of a town turning on its neighbours – review by Hannah J Davies in The Guardian. "Film-maker Jamie Roberts – whose previous documentaries include Angry, White and Proud and Ukraine: Enemy in the Woods – has form in finding people whose personal stories speak to a wider malaise, and letting them recount those stories in their own words. We aren’t told whether or not utilities manager turned anti-immigration activist Liam Tomsett is in the wrong for the way he behaves in his Sussex town of Crowborough, where he blocks contractors from making deliveries to an asylum centre. But it would be a stretch to say that Tomsett comes out of the programme looking overly reasonable – not least when he finds himself in an altercation with some of the contractors at the site, and is arrested and charged with common assault and possession of an offensive weapon.... If it wasn’t so horrific, parts of England ’Til I Die could almost feel like something written by Chris Morris. One woman launches into an extended rant about burqas, halal meat and dogs, while three men from the asylum centre whom Tomsett and a group of other men follow down the road turn out to be Iranian Christians on their way to church. Tomsett and his Crowborough Says No collaborator Gary believe that their actions are 'a fuck-you to the government'. But it seems the people they’re truly hurting are their own neighbours; as one anonymous contributor says, it’s a 'really horrible feeling' knowing that people in the town are protesting against others that look like her. Unsettling aerial camera work only emphasises the sense that Crowborough is becoming something of a strange and unknowable place, just not in the way that Tomsett claims. While much of this programme is highly upsetting to watch, Roberts leaves room for nuance... [he] also knows just when to chime in with a killer question: when Tomsett threatens a local business, he asks, 'Do you not stop for a moment [and think] that maybe they see you as the dangerous one …?' It’s an incredibly tough topic, but one that Roberts handles with care."

The Strangers by Naomi Alderman: where has this odd new species come from? – review by Keiran Goddard in The Guardian. "The Strangers, despite (or perhaps because of) its many ragged idiosyncrasies, is a remarkably successful evocation of loss. Narrated by 'the novelist Naomi Alderman', who is mourning both her recently deceased mother and a series of failed pregnancies, the book ranges incisively across the vast affective terrain bequeathed to those who go on living: despair, disorientation, solipsism, petulance, regret, resignation … the list goes on. After all, grief is not an emotion – it is all the emotions, all at once.... The plot itself is simple enough... A new type of species is discovered, a flat-faced and long-nosed mammal that comes to be known as a mimmoth. They remain largely inscrutable to humans: hard to photograph, even harder to capture, and seemingly responsible for a range of positive ecological changes.... Fundamentally, though, The Strangers is a deeply moving and wise book, asserting the painful truth that we simply do not get to choose the things that we lose. When the narrator wonders if she has fallen prey to 'mimmoth-psychosis', the delusion that one has a uniquely intimate relation with the mysterious creatures, I was put in mind of Judith Butler’s observation about grief being a site of temporal reorganisation, a crucible in which our selfhood can be undone and remade. Both Alderman and Butler seem to remind us that while despair may temporarily convince us otherwise, life, in all its terrifying potential, stubbornly persists."

I was asked to write a new Miss Marple, so I sent her to the Alps – article by Lucy Foley in The Guardian. “Like many readers, I was drawn to the Poirot books first…. It was only when I reread the books as an adult that I understood the genius of the character, and came to appreciate how clever and radical Christie had been in making an elderly spinster her master sleuth – occupying a space somewhere between that of a detective and a bystander. She had taken one of the ‘left behind‘ women – a figure typically both pitied and scorned by society for not having been able to find a partner after the first world war – and shown her running rings around the other characters, using her invisibility as a kind of superpower. And in creating Miss Marple, she had broken one of the oaths made by the Detection Club (of which Christie was a member) not to use ‘Feminine Intuition‘ as a means of solving the crime. So much in the Miss Marple books relies on her intuition: there are physical clues, yes, but it is her understanding of human nature, an understanding that is coded as specifically and peculiarly ‘female‘, that really wins the day.… I also loved that, while the Poirot books can feel quite timeless, the Marple books form a fascinating portrait of social change in Britain across the decades: the evolving landscape of the English village as documented between the 1930s setting of The Murder at the Vicarage and the 1950s period of The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side (in which a new housing estate has been built), the postwar unease about not knowing one’s neighbours in A Murder Is Announced and the swinging 60s raciness of At Bertram’s Hotel. All of which I came to appreciate anew when planning my own novel. I knew that Miss Marple herself was the key to it all, the element I had to get absolutely right.… I wanted my book to be in conversation with our own times. This wasn’t about shoe-horning in themes, but drawing out parallels between then and now. In doing so I wanted to interrogate modern society’s fear of ageing and the invisibility of old age that has hardly changed since Christie’s time. I wanted to highlight the prevalence of certain toxic male egos at the heart of culture and politics: figures who have attempted, at times, to rewrite history to further their own ends or disappear past misdeeds. All, apparently, with a total lack of consequence. Which brings me to another thing I love about Christie’s writing: the grim satisfaction of seeing the past catching up with the wicked. The meting out of just deserts. It may not be happening out there in the real world at the moment, but rest assured, it happens here.“

Britain’s Slave Traders by William A Pettigrew: the inconvenient truth – review by Joe Moran in The Guardian. “One tedious aspect of Britain’s post-imperial melancholia is the number of amateur historians who would rather we stopped going on about our role in the slave trade. Isn’t it all in the past? Weren’t we the first to abolish it anyway? … The erasure of this history began with the abolitionists, who quickly realised that identifying and shaming slave traders might harm their cause. They chose instead to argue that abolition would confirm Britain’s superior moral righteousness. Lauding abolition obscured what Pettigrew calls ’slave gain’: Britain’s gigantic profiting from the trade. … Since April 2021, Pettigrew has led a group of nine academic historians identifying all the known investors – about 13,000 of them – who financed Britain’s brutal trafficking of 3.3 million enslaved Africans, of whom about half a million died during the Atlantic crossing. The traffic began in the 1560s with a syndicate of city merchants, naval and state officials. It soon earned royal approval, because of the role it played in humiliating the Spanish, increasing influence in the New World, establishing a foothold in west Africa, and enlarging the royal purse. After the Glorious Revolution of 1688, English slave merchants loosened their ties with the monarchy and embraced a free market. The trade expanded beyond political and commercial elites, and out from London to the regions. Bristol and Liverpool shared out the trade in the 18th century, the latter perfecting and industrialising it.… Pettigrew tells the story straight, with little reference to today’s culture wars.… [His] careful tone is ultimately more effective than stridency. In this argument, slave traders cannot be conveniently separated out; they become central to the British project of economic and technological progress and cultural enlightenment.“

How a ​grassroots ​film ​is ​turning ​climate anxiety ​into ​action – First Edition newsletter by Libby Brooks, in The Guardian. “The People’s Emergency Briefing began life, in real life. Last November, nine climate experts delivered a ‘first-of-its-kind national emergency briefing’ to an audience of MPs, civic and business leaders in Westminster. It was, by all reports, a galvanising event. The organising team – including pioneer in carbon footprinting Prof Mike Berners-Lee and TV environmentalist Chris Packham – then crowdfunded to turn the in-person briefing into a film, which anyone can register to screen in their local village hall, faith centre, workplace or wherever else they can get bums on seats…. It’s a hard watch. The alarming – but never alarmist – message is that the climate is changing much faster than expected, and that we are woefully unprepared for it. The grinding frustration of these experts – who have been repeating these stark facts to a sclerotic government and a sceptical public for years – is evident, but there is also hope.… What’s unique about the film is both how it’s framed and how it’s watched. ‘We knew you can’t just film people talking at podiums,‘ [explains Nick Oldridge, co-founder of The People’s Emergency Briefing], ‘so we decided: “We’ll do it like Gogglebox”.‘ Spliced between the expert commentary, members of the public sit on a sofa across from Packham and talk about what they’ve just watched. ‘This is the nub of it,‘ says Oldridge. ‘This film has got to be watched in groups, people who experience it together and then talk about it, instead of the isolated way we usually consume media.’ Since the first community screening on 7 April, the film has become a word-of-mouth phenomenon – so far 2,789 screenings have taken place, with a further 1,395 planned.”

Andy Burnham talks about ‘public control’ of the utilities but it’s a minefield. We can lead him through it – article by Will Hutton and Andy Haldane in The Guardian. “Good governance typically involves seeking an appropriate balance between incentives and expertise. For public services, this means a set of incentives well aligned with the interests of customers – namely, the general public – while having the expertise to deliver services effectively. This underlines the perils of the privatised model. For example, Thames Water is owned by a consortium of investors, including highly leveraged hedge funds. This governance structure has no shortage of high-quality financial expertise. Unfortunately, this highly ‘innovative‘ (and leveraged) financing structure is singularly ill-suited to a low-risk public utility; investor incentives are horribly misaligned with the public good. Full nationalisation faces the opposite problems. In this scenario, the company’s incentives would be aligned, by statute, with the public good. But without commercial discipline and expertise, there are fewer reasons to expect it to be run expertly and efficiently…. For public utilities, then, ‘public control‘ should mean seeking governance structures with aims that are aligned with those of the general public…. What alternative governance structures strike a better balance than the extremes of nationalisation or privatisation? Aligning the incentives of utilities with those of the public could be done most easily and effectively by turning them into public-benefit companies with a primary, constitutional objective of delivering high-quality services, with profitability subordinate to that broader aim.… Importantly, the utility companies would go beyond ’benefit’ or B Corps (obliged to display high standards of social and environmental performance, transparency and accountability), and instead would have more demanding governance requirements, tailored to their needs and standards. …To strengthen further public incentives, executive pay could be linked to public-benefit outcomes. ,,, Lastly, this would imply a paradigm shift in the culture and architecture of regulation,,, Public-benefit utilities would be constitutionally obliged to want the same outcomes as public-interest regulators.”

Toxic bosses: why do companies protect managers who make working life hell? – article by Kathleen Saxton in The Guardian. “When Andrea finally resigned, her colleagues told her the truth they had always known about her boss. Some apologised. Others admitted they had watched what happened to her and said nothing. One offered the sentence I have been unable to forget: ‘You’ve been an emotional stab vest for us. You protected us.’… Stories like Andrea’s are usually told as stories about monsters: the bullying boss, the narcissistic founder who finally, spectacularly, falls. I have come to think of such framing as the least useful way to tell them. Instead, I’m interested in how such people keep acquiring power and why, once their behaviour is visible to almost everyone, nobody stops them.… Some of this starts at selection. Consider the language of the senior job specification: bold, decisive, resilient, charismatic, comfortable under pressure, possessed of ’executive presence’. There is nothing wrong with any of it. The problem is that a healthy leader and a dangerous one can look almost identical at interview. One candidate is decisive because they have experience and a secure enough ego to make the difficult call; another because doubt itself is intolerable. One is resilient through self-regulation, another through emotional detachment. Both interview beautifully. Corporate language launders the difference: low empathy is repackaged as decisiveness, ruthlessness as ’high standards’, emotional detachment as resilience, manipulation as influence.… As a therapist, I am also interested in what forms such leaders. Research published in the Leadership Quarterly found an association between supervisors’ experiences of family undermining during childhood and abusive supervisory behaviour in adulthood, particularly among those with lower self-control. This demands careful interpretation. Trauma in itself does not create toxic leaders and disqualifies nobody from leadership. Many remarkable leaders have transformed painful experience into empathy and wisdom. The distinction that matters is between trauma and unprocessed trauma.… There is a profound difference between a leader who has made sense of their lived experience and one whose unexamined wounds continue to seep into the way they use power. The child who survived chaos by monitoring everything can become the executive who must control everything. Somebody who once felt profoundly powerless may spend an adult lifetime making sure they never feel powerless again. The survival mechanisms do not necessarily disappear. They can professionalise. Hypervigilance becomes ‘strategic oversight‘. The inability to trust becomes ‘strong leadership‘. Emotional suppression becomes ‘composure under pressure‘. What once protected a person from vulnerability can become, under the authority of office, the very thing that makes everybody around them unsafe.“

Deep into the Sixties: Britain 1965-66 by David Kynaston: a tour de force of popular history – review by Blake Morrison in The Guardian. “Britain in the mid-60s is associated with Carnaby Street, the Beatles and miniskirts, not racism. But what Black people endured, from a colour bar on property to the abuse of Leeds United winger Albert Johanneson as a 'golliwog', is no less a period marker than Harold Wilson’s pipe, Twiggy’s haircut, Mary Whitehouse’s clean-up TV campaign and Bob Dylan’s use of an electric guitar. David Kynaston doesn’t underplay the excitements of the period. But he rightly emphasises that the rotten old 50s – patriarchal, homophobic, class-divided and bigoted – wouldn’t just fade away. His mammoth project, a history of Britain from 1945‑79, is now past halfway.… The challenge is to balance an in-depth account of politics, economics, industry, education and culture with personal stories of what it was like to be there: the food you ate, the clothes you wore, the films you saw. The sources he draws on range from statistical surveys and sociological reports to political biographies, personal diaries and the grouchy letters of Philip Larkin. No living historian is as comprehensive…. As well as giving us snippets from daily life and reminding us how nasty the 60s could be (Ian Brady, Myra Hindley and the Kray brothers), Kynaston devotes chapters to larger-scale cultural shifts, chief among them in education. Harold Wilson dreamed of ‘a Britain in which anyone can get to the top on merit and ability, not on social or family connections’, and the shift to comprehensive schools was integral to that.… Kynaston also explores the rebuilding of cities: slum clearances, tower blocks and … concrete and clay. It was a peak time for high rises, with whole streets destroyed (as if wartime bombing had resumed) and millions of people displaced to new estates. Some were grateful to escape the damp and squalor of the houses they’d been in; many were not… Happily, there was also a vogue for liberalisation: of birth control, abortion law, consensual sex between men, and greater opportunities for women. All were much needed: homosexuality was widely vilified; the Factories Act forbade women to do night shifts and only 80 of 1,707 candidates at the election were female; family planning clinics wouldn’t see young, unmarried women… More surprising is to find that half the workforce in 1966 was already in the service industry and that the City of London was a hub of global power long before the 1980s. The book’s likeliest readers will be those alive at the time, whose memories will be triggered by what was new (the Post Office Tower, microwaves, Laker Airways), what needed phasing out (bottom-pinching, outdoor loos, ‘the brain-damaging heaviness’ of leather footballs) and what songs, plays, films and television programmes had to say about contemporary life.”

On the Equality of All Things by Carlo Rovelli: a physicist’s guide to life, the universe and everything – review by Farrah Jarral in The Guardian. “Rovelli, who directs a quantum gravity research group in Marseille, has written several books on physics for the general reader, including the global bestseller Seven Brief Lessons on Physics. His latest is an attempt to integrate principles and theories from the discipline into a broader Weltanschauung: one of the essential unity of all things, and the profoundly relational and perspectival nature of the universe. ’Electrons and minds, stones and laws, judgments and galaxies do not essentially differ in nature from one another,’ he writes. ’They are notions that illuminate each other.’… The first lesson refers to his theory of relational quantum mechanics to ask us to abandon the notion that the world is made up of things with fixed properties. Rather, physical systems have properties relative to other physical systems. Also, everything’s moving, all the time, and there’s no fixed point around which we are in motion. The second lesson takes aim at the idea of linearity. Rovelli urges us to accept circularity and question the need to identify the ultimate foundation of things, when in fact, it’s turtles all the way down. The lessons continue. The world is not made up of things at all, but processes. It’s enough to give you vertigo, and Rovelli admits it. ‘The resulting image of reality is haunting. Every fact is only a fact relative to something else, and even the fact that a fact is relative to something else is itself relative. There is no ground floor.’ Yet, in contrast to the bleakness that can shroud such unflinching scientific accounts of the universe, Rovelli’s telling validates our messy, subjective human experiences. ‘None of this prevents us from describing the world from one perspective. Ours.’ But the physics tells us that our perspectives are just that, and that there may be others.“

AI predictions: seven ways you can tell useful thinking from sci-fi fantasies – substack post (‘Whatever Works’) by Naomi Alderman. “In the past couple of weeks, there have been many news stories about how AI could kill us all within the decade. I look at all of this with a weary disbelief, thinking: How is it possible that people are taking this as seriously as they are when it is clearly a science fiction story? Not that there are no dangers from AI. But the story ‘will kill us all in within the decade’ is just a story, not reality…. Here are some clues. None by themselves are definitive. But the more of these things are true, the more likely it is you’re looking not at a sober diagnosis of where we are but at a piece of bad sci-fi.… 1. There is an end to the story. The real world doesn’t end. Stories end.… 2. The prediction is simple, extremely compressed and can be expressed in a couple of sentences.… That’s because a story is a tiny tiny sliver of reality, it’s a kind of extract or concentrate of a small portion of reality. But reality is very very big. It is the map that is the same size as the territory. Nothing about it can be boiled down or extracted…. 3. The prediction gives you such a strong feeling that it stops you from thinking. Stories are wildly entertaining.… That’s what stories are for. They hook into deep parts of your mind and draw you into them so that, for a time, they seem more real than the world around you. They make you laugh and cry, they stir your emotions in the way that very little in an ordinary boring day does. Reality is quite emotionally flat most of the time. ... But stories must be constantly interesting and emotional… 4. Related but distinct: the prediction is incredibly interesting and compelling (because reality is mostly quite boring). If a prediction about AI is not quite boring I would take it with a huge ladle of salt. actually, I want to be even more specific than calling this feeling boring. we are looking for a dull, leaden feeling where you go, ‘Oh yes, of course, that is how the world works. The world doesn’t work like stories. It is sullen like this.‘… 5. You can actually name a piece of sci-fi with this prediction as a plot point. … The reason it feels so plausible, my friends, is because you have seen it in a movie. Not because it is in fact really plausible. 6. The prediction does not include the effects of people making predictions in it (or other knock-on effects). In a story, people don’t know they’re in a story. Events unfold like a nightmare, everyone keeps walking into the crisis. (This is because being reasonable and thinking things through is boring, and stories must always be fascinating.) In reality, we are constantly talking about what may happen next and how to mitigate it.… 7. The prediction says the future will suddenly be evenly distributed. … A lot of these predictions about what’s going to happen with AI presume that everybody will immediately adopt whatever technology it is, that there will be no resistance, that there will be no bureaucracy, and that there will be no rival systems. Suddenly, it will happen everywhere. Human life has never worked like this. If you’re imagining that all human life is suddenly in lockstep in any way you are imagining a different species to us and you’ve written a science fiction story.“

Saturday, 14 November 2026

Cuttings: August 2026

Tao of Glass: stage magic as McDermott meditates on the minimalist master – review by Alexandra Coghlan in The Guardian. "Premiered at 2019’s Manchester International festival, this beguiling meditation now makes its London debut – albeit without the figure who looms tousle-haired and scowling behind it: composer Philip Glass. Glass’s music has been, McDermott explains, a 'river' through his life. The award-winning director’s fascination started as a teenager, lying on his bedroom floor listening to Glassworks on repeat, later crystallised by a little light stalking (the young McDermott follows Glass through the streets of Covent Garden) and professional collaborations on the composer’s operas. But it’s a show they never made together – an adaptation of Maurice Sendak’s In The Night Kitchen, derailed by the author’s death – that becomes the catalyst for a series of theatrical vignettes for McDermott, a trio of puppeteers and quartet of musicians, each set to a specially composed piece by Glass. All coalesce around Glass’s own question: where does music come from?"

Could a couch-to-5k for books get you back into reading? – article by Naomi Alderman in The Guardian. "Do you feel that it’s harder to read than it used to be? ... Harder to sit down and lose yourself in a book? ... Do you feel that you used to have a life-sustaining reading habit, everything from fun popcorn novels to serious nonfiction, classic and contemporary, many genres and writers, but somehow it’s gone away?... It is, of course, the damn phones.... It’s a public health crisis of intellectual health, and most governments don’t seem minded to do anything about it. ... While we’re waiting, if nobody is going to do it for us, for now, we’re going to need to do what we can for ourselves. So I thought about the couch to 5k for reading, how you could do it. I worked on designing the couch to 5k for my running app Zombies, Run several years ago, so I know the theory. When I mentioned the idea on my Substack newsletter, Whatever Works, readers bit my hand off with excitement (much like a zombie). It suddenly seemed very urgent. There is no more time to wait.... So I’ve designed a program. Eight weeks, with three separate tracks. It’s mostly for people like me, who remember that they had a life-sustaining reading habit once but feel that it has somehow fallen away.... The response has been extraordinary. After the first week of the program, people are already saying that they’re finding their morning routine goes more quickly now they’re not brain-fogged from scrolling first thing, that reading in stressful times is making them feel calmer and not more anxious as scrolling did, that they can watch a long film without being tempted to look at their phone. They are rediscovering the simple joy of being gripped by a great book after as few as two or three days of working on this together.... There is so much joy in books, and it’s all still there waiting for us. All we have to do is take it back from the technology billionaires, one day of reading at a time."

Web of billions: how Spider-Man became the most heroic franchise in Hollywood – article by Jesse Hassenger in The Guardian. "A year ago, the superhero-industrial complex looked like it was on the wane.... But look out, as the song goes: here comes Spider-Man. Spider-Man: Brand New Day, the fourth solo film starring Tom Holland as the third live-action iteration of the character in the past 25 years, was always expected to do well at the box office this summer.... Yet a few months ago, hardly anyone predicted that it would swoop so far as the all-time opening weekend record in North America, outgrossing Avengers: Endgame with $360m, and coming in a strong second worldwide, making nearly a billion dollars within four days.... It doesn’t feel like a coincidence that all three live-action Spider-Man actors dated their co-stars at some point; these are superhero movies that reboot and reconfigure and recast, but never fully dispense with romance. At first, that was very much part of MCU at large; the first two Iron Man movies run on screwball-adjacent byplay between Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr) and Pepper Potts (Gwyneth Paltrow). But as romance leached out of the MCU following Phase One, replaced with weirdly businesslike allusions to off-screen hookups and breakups, Spider-Man remained at least a little bit lovelorn, perhaps reminding audiences of a crucial human angle missing from big-scale smash-em-ups. It’s not just the love stories that continually draw audiences to Spider-Man, of course. The character has long resonated as a keen fusion of longtime DC titans Superman and Batman: he’s got the diverse (and potentially playful) power set like Superman, paired with a Clark Kent-like humble-nerd identity; and the relatable angst of Batman, who of course has no fantastical powers and, as such, bumps up against his human limitations. He wasn’t the first Marvel hero, but he’s probably the archetypal one, mixing in more overt teen melodrama in an era where Superman was flying further into sci-fi territory."

AI models have been going rogue in tests – how worried should we be? – article by Dan Milmo in The Guardian. "Two cutting-edge AI models have targeted real people and organisations in the latest safety scare to hit the technology. The UK’s AI Security Institute (AISI) said the incident was unprecedented but could become more common as the technology becomes increasingly capable.... In the most serious incident, the Mythos agent decided that hacking users on GitHub – a platform used by software developers – would enable it to deploy a piece of software that would allow it to pass the test. It set up accounts with fake online identities and used them to target a software developer on GitHub with the power to approve its malicious code. It also sent emails carrying malware to other individuals... The institute said the models were showing deceptive behaviour it had not seen before. In one example, the Mythos agent signed off a message on GitHub in Danish to try to convince the Danish-speaking developer it was genuine. In another tactic it used a fake GitHub account to agree with its assertions that the malware it was pushing at developers was not dangerous."

John Berger: From Life by Tom Overton: a vibrant biography of the pioneering critic – review by Xan Brooks in The Guardian. "These days Berger’s reputation largely rests on Ways of Seeing, the insurrectionist 1972 BBC series which made him the critics’ equivalent of a rock star or cult leader.... Overton, though, is at pains to stitch Ways of Seeing into its wider context – showing it as part of a continuum, one political project among many. His exuberant biography is thick with detail and lit by wonder. It strains to paint the whole canvas and give us the man in full, warts and all.... Overton reveres Berger but he is frustrated by him, too. His life’s a hot mess; his very presence turns oppressive. He’s so authoritative on the page and so contradictory in the wild, a jumble of red-blooded Marxism and High Tory traditionalism. Berger writes elegantly and angrily about forced migration, mourning the loss of the old rural communities, but he lives as a self-imposed exile in Switzerland and France, splitting his time between different houses and women.... If there was a bright running thread through Berger’s portmanteau career, it was this preoccupation with the past and its connection to the present. The dead and the living are interdependent, he said. The stronger the link, the happier and healthier the society. Great paintings in a gallery allow us to travel in time. So too do some people, if they are skilled and sensitive enough. Berger’s 1967 book A Fortunate Man paid gorgeous tribute to Dr John Sassall, a country physician from the Forest of Dean whose work at times bordered on the supernatural. 'The doctor,' Berger wrote, 'is the familiar of death … the living intermediary between us and the multitudinous dead.' He might just as easily be talking about the role of great artists and critics."

A History of the Novel in Britain by Philip Hensher: a masterpiece of criticism – review by Kathryn Hughes in The Guardian. "In his opening paragraph, Philip Hensher declares that a novel not only 'tells a good story' but is a good story in itself. We could extend that neat formula to include this book, which is not only a masterful account of fiction since 1719, when Daniel Defoe set Robinson Crusoe down on his desert island, but is itself a wonderful read. There is nothing dreary here; no sense of being back in the seminar room taking notes. Instead it is 600 pages of deep pleasure, an excuse to revisit old literary loves and be reminded of ones that have slipped from view. Hensher is smart enough to know why his book works so well and vain enough to tell us. The usual methodology for a survey is to assemble a roster of academics and invite them to trot out a chapter on their specialism, whether that be 'Thomas Hardy' or 'High Modernism'. The result is a series of silos, with little sense of historical connection or intellectual unfolding. Hensher, by contrast, gives us a joined-up account of creative call and response. Equally crucial to this project’s success is Hensher’s own experience as a novelist. He brings a practitioner’s informed eye to such questions as why some chapters in Dickens’s Dombey and Son are in the present tense or how Henry James pulls off free indirect speech in What Maisie Knew.... Hensher never falls into crankiness, but he is unafraid to point out home truths. Such as the fact that so much of the pleased-with-itself 'experimentalism' of the 1960 to 1980 period was merely a retread of things that had been done better before.... Hensher doesn’t bring his account right up to date, preferring to stop in 2000 – at Zadie Smith and her 'wonderful ear for speech' – on the grounds that it is impossible to form a proper critical judgment until plenty of time has passed. It is a wise decision and a tactful one, underscoring the moral seriousness of this master­piece, quite aside from its buoyant joy. Reader, I could not put it down."

From grey water to cool spaces: 10 climate crisis policies Britain needs right now – article by Matthew Taylor Sandra Laville, Damian Carrington and Pippa Neill in The Guardian. "Here are 10 policies that Andy Burnham’s government should consider announcing urgently. 1. Reject drilling licences for the Jackdaw and Rosebank oil and gasfields... 2. Increase windfall tax on fossil fuel giants to pay for adaptation measures... 3. Make grey water reuse mandatory in new buildings and incentivise rainwater harvesting... 4. Bring the water industry under national control... 5. Invest in proper equipment for firefighters... 6. Implement a maximum workplace temperature... 7. Fund cool spaces in every community... 8. Launch a national retrofit programme... 9. Plant more trees and protect existing nature... 10. Encourage regenerative agriculture approaches to increase food resilience."

‘Houses with long histories are magical’: David Olusoga on the home history show that’s gripped the UK – article by David Olusoga in The Guardian. "Almost a decade ago, while we were filming the first series of A House Through Time for BBC Two, I was not at all convinced that this was a show that had the potential to break through.... I was concerned that audiences would struggle to understand why we had locked ourselves into the straitjacket of a single house.... I worried that perhaps I was too close to the subject and that only historians of the city would find the show compelling. I was, it turned out, doing what TV producers are infamous for doing. I was underestimating the audience.... Like everyone who presents TV shows, I am regularly stopped on the street by people who recognise me from their screen. Most often what they want to talk about is A House Through Time. Amazingly, that remains the case even after I appeared on the great TV juggernaut of our time: The Celebrity Traitors. The first question I am asked by the fans of A House Through Time is almost always the same: when is the next series coming out? So I am left to wonder why a show about which I had doubts has been such a hit. What had I not appreciated 10 years ago? What I didn’t get back then, above all, is what old houses mean to the people who live in them. Houses with long histories are magical places.... A House Through Time reveals – in incredible detail – the sorts of human stories that would tumble out of our own home if only we had the time to go looking. It reminds us that houses have longer lives than we do. That no matter how many years or decades we live in them, our time there represents a single chapter in their far longer story.... Only TV – and let’s be more specific, only public service TV – would invest the time and money needed to uncover history at this level of granularity. Only TV would believe that the stories of ordinary people – not kings or presidents or movie stars – could grip audiences of millions. And only TV is capable of assembling teams of specialist researchers, assistant producers, producer/directors, series producers and executive producers with the skills needed to track down the thousands of documents that become the jigsaw pieces that make up the bigger historical puzzle.... If there is another reason to explain why A House Through Time has caught on it is that the series plays a small part in a bigger story: the expansion of history. History has for decades been getting bigger and more inclusive. History is no longer just about 'great men'. The emergence of social history, working-class history, women’s history and imperial history has uncovered the lives of people once deemed of little interest. The genealogy revolution has made millions of people into amateur historians. Today our ancestors – all of them, no matter how humble their lives – are deemed worthy of study and remembrance."

What end-of-life experts know about living well: love your wrinkles, celebrate birthdays and don’t obsess over work – article by Sarah Phillips in The Guardian. "We will all face death one day, but our attitude towards this is individual. How can our understanding of mortality shape our approach to life? Here, palliative care doctors and death doulas share what they know about the end – and how it informs the way they live.... Prioritise people, not things... Keep work in proportion... Know that pleasure isn’t everything... Be at one with nature... Live with intention... Focus on the small things... Be a completist... Connect with others... Don’t worry about signs of ageing... Try to stay healthy – but don’t let it limit your life... Celebrate birthdays... Have a bucket list – and make it happen... Talk about the kind of death you would like."

The weekend is 100 years old, but have ‘skiveday Fridays’ and hybrid working ruined it for everyone? – article by Jess Cartner-Morley in The Guardian. "Remarkably, the concept of the weekend as we know it is only 100 years old. In 1926, Henry Ford changed the shape of the week, announcing that the workers at his factories would now do five eight-hour days instead of six, with no cut in pay. Ford did not invent the weekend – the idea had been bubbling under for a century, in campaigns by trade unions, religious groups and progressive employers – but by putting his considerable industrial weight behind it, the two-day chunk of freedom was born. 'It is high time to rid ourselves of the notion that leisure for workmen is either lost time or a class privilege,' Ford wrote in his company’s Ford News in October 1926. Ford’s innovation was in part a response to his earlier invention: the assembly line, which had increased productivity but exhausted workers, with absenteeism up to 10% in factories; in his article he did not disguise that there was self-interest involved. 'People who have more leisure require more transportation in vehicles,' he continued. The new fashion for day trips was an effective marketing device to sell cars. Meanwhile, his factories maintained a steady level of productivity despite the reduced hours. In 1938, faced with rising unemployment levels in the Great Depression, the five-day week was officially adopted across the US."

Democracy v the machine: the birth of the digital age and the warnings that were ignored – article by Jill Lepore in The Guardian, based on her book The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State. "Across the second half of the 20th century, liberal democracy made possible the rise of the artificial state. It didn’t make it inevitable. The digital revolution didn’t have to play out the way it did in the realm of politics and government; it played out the way it did because of the failure of liberal democracy to limit corporate power over politics and government, its failure to heed decades of warnings about the dangers of an automated state. Techno-libertarianism, which married the technocracy crusade of the 1930s – an anti-democracy movement led, in the US, by Elon Musk’s grandfather – to the computopianism of the 1980s, was born in the 1990s. Beginning in the previous decade, Silicon Valley had fallen under the spell of the libertarian Ayn Rand. Rand had been a cult figure of the far right since the publication in 1943 of her novel The Fountainhead, and she became even better known after the 1957 publication of Atlas Shrugged. Rand embraced radical individualism and saw a very narrow role for the state in human affairs, arguing that every individual ought to be completely free to pursue personal gain through heroic, self-interested achievement.... Under the influence of Rand, the internet became what conservatives and techno-libertarians wanted it to become.... One of the contract’s earliest manifestos appeared – online – in 1996, John Perry Barlow’s A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace: 'Governments of the industrial world, you weary giants of flesh and steel, I come from cyberspace, the new home of Mind. On behalf of the future, I ask you of the past to leave us alone,' Barlow wrote.... Libertarian futurists weren’t the only people proposing new rules for cyberspace; they just happened to be the people who ended up making the rules. In 1995, Michael Hauben, a computer science student at Columbia University and an active user of Usenet (he coined the term 'netizen'), drafted a Proposed Declaration of the Rights of Netizens. He saw himself as a leader of what he described as 'the fight to keep the net an uncommercialised public commons'.... Douglas Adams, the author of the 1970s satirical science fiction series The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, had a vision for the internet, too.... In 2001, both Adams and Hauben died, the former of a heart attack and the latter, at the age of 29, after an accident. Their frameworks for free and equal access to an internet structured by public interest, not commercial interest, died with them. But by then, the techno-libertarians had already won."

Here is the news from the US: Woke 1.0 is over. But what did progressives do wrong? – article by Nasrine Malik in The Guardian. "This rush to the future away from what some perceive to be an embarrassing past groups together various disparate phenomena. But I’m afraid it’s not that simple. Woke 1.0 ... was about politics and culture and also about the behaviours and trends it triggered. It was about concrete problems: policing of minority communities, the right of women not to be sexually harassed or violated, the systemic racism and sexism that damaged both. And it was about reforming the cultural structures that created and perpetuated those systems; asking university curricula to expand and diversify intellectual sources, recognising the long shadow of glorified imperial histories, and updating institutions – from the media to the academy – in order to enfranchise change.... What did happen is that accompanying those movements was an adoption of postures and behaviours that signalled that one was on the right side.... An altogether more serious – and shallow – allegation is that it was all 'crazy' because this is what the left does. Given a chance, the left will waste capital by descending into infighting, radicalism and alienation. It is rarely acknowledged that this left never has political power, and so its energies become trapped in the realm of culture. This is not to excuse excesses, but to point out a mundane matter of physics. When a political movement is deprived of executive means, by way of democratic systems in which money and establishment interests are arrayed behind the right and the centre right, it becomes trapped outside policy and exercises its power in the only venues it can. It is a feature of weakness, not strength."

Can anyone be too poor to buy a toothbrush? Yes, I know, because that was me – article by Katriona O'Sullivan in The Guardian. "Someone from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation was on [Nick Ferrari's LBC radio show] discussing research showing that about 7 million people are struggling to afford basic essentials, including toothpaste and toothbrushes... [Ferrari talked] about the price of cheap toothbrushes in pound shops and at Asda....Had I been on the show, I would have brought both my lived experience and my academic knowledge to the argument. I would have explained why a person living in poverty might buy cheap wine instead of a cheap toothbrush.... One of the first questions we ask, often without realising it, is whether the thing we are buying will help us now or later.... A toothbrush is an investment in the future. So is going for a run. So is buying healthier food that costs more and takes longer to prepare. The benefit is delayed. Poverty, on the other hand, creates urgent problems. The debt collector is knocking at your door for his money. The electricity is about to run out. The school is asking for payment for a trip. Your son is being bullied because he is wearing cheap trainers instead of Nikes. These things feel immediate. The possible dental problems caused by not replacing a toothbrush feel far away.... [Also] long-term planning becomes more difficult during periods of stress. It is also shaped by how and where you grow up. If you are raised in an environment where life feels unstable and the future feels uncertain, it can be much harder to believe that sacrificing today will bring a reward tomorrow.... That is part of the reason poverty is associated with higher levels of addiction and criminality. Not because poor people are naturally reckless or immoral, but because deprivation, stress and hopelessness shape our brains and our behaviour.... My parents did not brush their teeth or ours. Looking after your teeth was not something I had been taught to value. ... When I was living on around £35 a week benefits in the 1990s, I sometimes bought three bottles of Diamond White rather than spending 50p on tampons. You might judge me for that. But when you live in shit, when nobody seems to care about you and you have stopped caring about yourself, a few bottles can feel like an escape. It felt easier to stuff my knickers with toilet roll from the cash-in-hand job I worked and have one night away from the misery than to sit sober with the constant belief that I was failing myself and my son. At times, it felt like the choice was three bottles or dying. That may seem hard to understand when your life has always contained safety, options and hope. But all you have to do is ask yourself one important question – would anyone choose that type of life if they could choose another? The answer to that is simple."

Will AI give you the job? Automated hiring tools spark discrimination and secrecy lawsuits – article by Arielle Pardes in The Guardian. "For the last four years, Erin Kistler has applied for thousands of jobs at companies like Paypal, Microsoft and Netflix, only to find her résumé disappear into a black hole. A product manager with nearly 20 years of experience, Kistler believes she was qualified for every role, yet she never received a single interview. Now, Kistler is suing Eightfold AI, the Silicon Valley maker of hiring software used by hundreds of companies, including those where she applied, in a class-action lawsuit. The case, filed in January in California court, is one of the first to argue that automated screening functions as an undisclosed consumer report or applicant dossier, ranking job applicants on their likelihood of success without giving them the chance to see or challenge the results, according to Kistler’s legal team. The lawsuit is one of several new legal battles over companies’ use of AI in employment decisions. Workers are also suing Meta over an internal AI system that allegedly targeted them for layoffs because they took parental or medical leave. And a recent lawsuit against IBM alleges that AI tools discriminated against older workers.... Experts who study this type of software say it can also introduce or exacerbate bias that could follow candidates across companies. Lawmakers are taking notice. The outcomes of the legal battles could shape future employment practices, transparency around them and the power candidates have in the process.... While human hiring managers can be unfair – choosing the applicant who was in the same fraternity, for example – 'the magnitude of bias is even stronger [with AI],' says Xuechunzi Bai, assistant professor at the University of Chicago who has researched hiring bias. Bai co-authored a recent study where AI models were asked to make hiring decisions about fictional applicants assigned to made-up demographic groups called Tufa, Aima, Reku and Weki. After a few rounds of hiring decisions, the AI models made inferences about candidates that had nothing to do with their qualifications, in effect stereotyping them. If one Tufa was a good doctor, then Tufa candidates were more likely to be chosen as doctors, and Weki candidates were more likely to be hired as janitors. The study found greater bias in AI than in human hiring decisions she examined last year. It also found that newer and more advanced models produced hiring decisions with more bias."

‘It exists only for pleasure’: does ice-cream have a future in the age of wellness fads and weight-loss drugs? – article by Kitty Drake in The Guardian. "Wall’s, one of the oldest brands under the Magnum umbrella, started selling ice-cream from a factory in Acton, London, in 1922. Wall’s was originally a butcher’s, and the company pivoted to ice-cream as a kind of summer-proof sausage equivalent, because meat wasn’t selling well in the heat. Ice-cream street traders have existed in the UK since the 1850s, when they used horse-drawn carts. But with the advent of mechanical refrigeration in the early 20th century, it became possible to mass-produce ice-cream. As British people began to buy freezers in the late 70s, it was rolled out to supermarkets. The 80s – which food writer Ruby Tandoh has called the 'golden age' of British ice-cream – saw the invention of Twister, Viennetta, Calippo and Feast.... For decades food companies have employed scientists to work out how to keep you eating without stopping long enough to remember you have a body. Food technologists have learned how to balance carbohydrate-to-fat ratios so a food can slow down or bypass the brain’s 'satiety signal' which tells you you’ve had enough. Technologists know how to design energy-dense food that dissolves so fast on your tongue, you immediately crave more. Ice-creams are usually too cold to emit odour, so Mars has worked out how to rub chocolate and caramel scent molecules into the ribbing of their ice-cream packets; they want you to begin salivating from the moment you tear one open. Magnum has hired technologists to engineer the chocolate casing on its ice-cream, so when you bite in, it doesn’t shatter into too many pieces and distract you by falling down your top. Everything has been specially designed to make you forget yourself – and your flesh – and keep chasing the next bite. By contrast, the selling point of Magnum’s new ice-creams seems to be they will keep you laser-focused on your own body. [Michelle Neville, Magum's behavioural scientist,] explained that the brand is trying to sell ice-cream to a customer who sees their 'food as medicine'. 'Now, even with a basic cereal bar, some people expect it to help metabolic resilience, control glycaemic index, improve gut health,' she said.... This latest drive to market ice-cream as a 'functional' food – something you eat not because it tastes nice, but because you believe it has some kind of nutritious, medicinal value – ... feels striking. Because more than any other food – more even than chocolate – ice-cream’s only real reason for existing is pleasure. A perfect mix of fat, sugar and at least 20% air, ice-cream was not invented to nourish you. First served in Europe in the early 1500s, it debuted in England as a magical kind of 'table trick'. Guests would look on while a servant churned, and a mass of sugary ice was transformed before their eyes into a strange, sweet foam. The Victorians ate ice-cream at balls and whittled it into enormous, campy ice sculptures, modelling pineapples, huge swans and whole bunches of flowers. With the arrival of the motorised ice-cream van in the 1920s in the UK and the birth of the 99 Flake, ice-cream became ever more connected in the British imagination with holidays and summer. The fact that ice-cream is essentially frivolous is a key part of its allure. It melts, so it almost demands that the eater give themselves up to the moment. The period between unwrapping an ice-cream and it collapsing into a puddle is a window in time, specially cordoned off for pleasure. You have to enjoy it or it will disappear without you. An ice-cream is a bit like a lit cigarette in that way.

The country of my birth has lost its heart’: Miriam Margolyes on how to fix broken Britain – article by Miriam Margolyes in The Guardian, extracted from her book Full English. "A funny thing happened on the way to 2026: I got old and the world turned nasty. It happened very quickly and it’s to do with politics (the world) and pelvic floor weakness (mine).... The Britain I grew up in, though – that feels almost unrecognisable, and everyone I speak to says the same thing. The historian Eric Hobsbawm, whom I knew and loved, argued that people invent the past they want for their own purposes – that the real past was quite different: 'Today is the great age of historical mythology.' He’s right, but that past is still the safe haven I’d like to return to. People feel adrift, they don’t understand or feel a connection to the place they thought they knew.... The things we took for granted – free speech, the Post Office, our local bank, even the home telephone – are disappearing. The US is an enemy. Evil oligarchs and their influence stalk the world, my world, your world. In recent times, the archbishop of Canterbury resigned and north London Jews are afraid to wear a Magen David (Shield or Star of David) necklace outside their homes for fear of being attacked. You’re brave to open your mouth these days. Indeed, many have demanded I keep mine shut. But I can’t. The present has become threatening, hostile and unwelcoming to us – much as our shores must feel to asylum seekers, as they scramble for a foothold in our United Kingdom. It also feels as though the country of my birth has lost its heart. How did we get here?... The history of the British Isles is full of painful moments and terrible decisions. And we need to face those. It’s much easier to look away from bad things that happened and, as with a fart, hope no one noticed. (Spoiler: everyone noticed.) Like every multinational corporation, Great Britain plc has done a lot of harm in its long life. The choice of red to represent the British empire on the global map feels entirely apt.... History has always been the propaganda of the victors, but it can lead you astray. So why not try listening to the other side of the story? Don’t fall for your own hype. It all seems heroic if you turn it into a monologue about why you were right all along, instead of facing the painful bits from which there’s no way you can come out well.... Our British history needs to reflect our mother tongue, which is a patchwork of words gathered from the different tribes and peoples who’ve made these islands home. There’s room for everyone: we all bring something to the table, whether invader or inhabitant.... I refuse to be cut off from the wealth of possibilities that Britain and Ireland offer. Let’s live, have fun, learn new tastes, new words, new mastications. Build bridges, cross chasms. And before we go to the moon again, let’s reap the benefits strangers in our midst offer. It’s not their fault that things are tough. It’s ours."

Largest review of its kind confirms benefits of tai chi and other Chinese exercises – article by Andrew Gregory in The Guardian. "Traditional Chinese exercises such as tai chi can offer wide-ranging benefits for people with musculoskeletal disorders, improving physical function, pain, mental health, sleep quality and bone mineral density, according to the largest review of its kind.... There was already evidence indicating traditional Chinese exercises were associated with beneficial health outcomes in people with musculoskeletal disorders, but much of it was fragmented and contained inconsistencies. The overarching review of pooled data analyses of systematic reviews by researchers at hospitals and universities in China, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, drew on 92 data syntheses from 1,744 randomised controlled clinical trials. It found 'high certainty evidence' for the effectiveness of traditional Chinese exercise – such as tai chi, qigong, baduanjin, wuqinxi and yijinjing – for a range of health outcomes for people with musculoskeletal disorders.... Tai chi, in particular, significantly eased chronic musculoskeletal pain and stiffness in several conditions while increasing bone mineral density in participants with osteopenia or osteoporosis, the research found. Maximum benefits were achieved when people did these exercises for longer than six months, at least three times a week, clocking up a total of at least 150 minutes a week."

How to spot a psychopath: ‘It’s like the difference between a domestic cat and a wild cat’ – article by Zoe Williams in The Guardian. "The classic checklist for psychopathy was developed in 1980 by Prof Robert Hare, who is still the recognised giant of the territory. The 20 traits, which ranged from pathological lying to a lack of empathy, were based entirely on prison populations. This worked because not only did Hare have the benefit of a large sample, with pronounced psychopathic behaviours, but he was able to compare interviews and self-reporting with data collected about the individuals – so inconsistencies could be identified. However, Hare knew this approach was limited.... It wasn’t from a forensic psychology but a business studies background that Dr Karen Mitchell arrived in the territory of high-functioning psychopathy.... Her work tended to be with organisations in crisis... Observing the sheer number of problems at work that stemmed from specific individuals with predatory traits, she started to research those same 'dark personality' behaviours in other precincts.... Mitchell’s interviews are remarkable. People from very different fields say alarmingly similar things: there’s one question about whether the interviewee had themselves ever been frightened of a persistent predatory personality (bear in mind that these weren’t victims, they were seasoned professionals) and the answers came back: 'I constantly worry that he will ruin my career' (from an HR person); 'I worry that they will … want to seek revenge' (from a social worker); 'I am pretty sure there are no lengths to which this man would not go to, to see that I am destroyed' (expert practitioner from the charity sector). These and arguably every statement from the interviews are so extreme that you can’t imagine saying them socially because you would sound mad – which some testimonies explicitly address.... Mitchell built a template of 20 attributes, divided into four clusters, and 25 tactics that would identify a high-functioning persistent predatory personality type. Cluster one includes a need for control; a grandiose sense of self; pathological inner response to challenge; vengefulness; refusal to compromise. Cluster two includes being predatory or exploitative; sadistic and cruel; having a low regard for laws, agreements, social and moral codes; no boundaries in sexual relationships; unreasonable expectations of others. Cluster three relates to the truth: Dark Personalities cultivate a façade of normality; they are chameleon-like; dishonest; devious and manipulative; and unwilling to accept responsibility for the negative impacts they cause. Finally, cluster four is around the Dark Personality’s own interior life: their emotions are acted and they do not experience affinity or the joy that comes with it; they are callous and devoid of empathy; unremorseful; self-interested; and brazen."

We already live in ‘clone towns’: AI is making things worse – column by John Naughton in The Observer. "In 2004 the New Economics Foundation (NEF) conducted a national survey of UK high streets, which were then still economically active. It found that real local shops had been replaced by swathes of identikit chain stores, making high streets up and down the country virtually indistinguishable from one another... A 'home town' is a place that retains its individual character and is instantly recognisable and distinctive to the people who live there, as well as those who visit. A 'clone town', in contrast, is a place that has had the individuality of its high street shops replaced by a 'monochrome strip of global and national chains'. Which meant that its retail heart could easily be mistaken for dozens of other bland town centres across the country.... This lack of diversity is not just confined to towns. It’s everywhere. You see it in property ads for new flats, or houses that have been modernised for resale.... Or cafes with exposed brickwork, and an expectation that oat milk with flat whites and smashed avocado are what you want. Or the legion of young influencers on Instagram who seem increasingly undistinguishable. What’s driving this, apparently inexorable, onward march to uniformity?... The tech industry calls it AI but it’s really machine-learning. It’s software that tries to predict what you’re likely to want next.... These machines are basically statistical guessers. They’re trained by being given an objective – a measure of the thing they’re supposed to maximise – and a loss function, which is essentially a penalty for making bad guesses. And, as the social data scientist Lauren Leek explains in a brilliant Substack post, Temperature Zero for Culture: Why Everything Is Starting to Look the Same, it’s the loss function that drives these machines – and their unsuspecting users – to blandness. This is because the most common loss function is the 'squared error' one.... This means that it really punishes big discrepancies. Which, in turn, means that the machine’s algorithm always plays safe by predicting the average of all the available possibilities. And in the process, it squashes ideas that were wild but also potentially original.... The NEF’s clone towns weren’t the product of some co-ordinated plan to homogenise Britain, but the emergent outcome of many thousands of separate independent decisions, each one taken in its own context.... Leek’s insight is that, in an AI-driven world, mathematics can explain why something such as that keeps happening, at every scale, from the high street to the streaming platform: any system trained to minimise error will always retreat towards the average, because the average is the safest guess when you’re not quite sure. Multiply that single fact across billions of daily recommendations, and you get a world that’s beginning to feel eerily familiar, everywhere. In that sense, the flat white with oat milk isn’t a coincidence. It’s the product of a loss function, working exactly as intended."