Thursday 8 August 2019

Cuttings: July 2019

'I feel terrified, betrayed': messages show strain on Jack Letts' parents – article by Caroline Davies in The Guardian. A letter to his parents from Jack Letts, who left the UK to join ISIS: "You lot brought me up without faith. You taught me and indoctrinated me to look down on religious people as brainwashed idiots [you know you did]. You taught me that life had no true purpose … that there’s no afterlife and therefore no final justice. You taught me disbelief and darkness. Why should I be grateful for that?"

Oliver Twiss and Martin Guzzlewit: the fan fiction that ripped off Dickens – article by Alison Flood in The Guardian, about Edward Lloyd and His World, eds Rohan McWilliam and Sarah Louise Lill. "Oliver Twiss was one of many plagiarisms of Dickens published by the press baron Edward Lloyd, with Barnaby Budge, Martin Guzzlewit, The Penny Pickwick and Nickelas Nickelbery also hitting shelves in the mid-19th century.... The imitations were much cheaper than the originals – The Penny Pickwick cost a penny, compared with a shilling for Dickens’ story. 'It’s very likely that, given these things saturated the market for a while, from about 1837 to 1845, many working-class readers first encountered Dickens not through his original works but in these weird doppelgangers that were going around,' says McWilliam.... After publishing The Penny Pickwick, Lloyd went on to build a publishing empire. He told the illustrators of his 'penny dreadfuls' – grisly horror novels that included the first appearance of the demon barber of Fleet Street, Sweeney Todd, and Varney the Vampire – 'There must be blood … much more blood!' 'When we think of the 1840s, we think of the publication of major novels such as Jane Eyre and Vanity Fair,” says McWilliam. “The reality is that many readers were as likely to be consuming shockers issued by Lloyd, such as Ada the Betrayed.' "

Hello World by Hannah Fry: AI and why we over-trust what we don’t understand – review by Katy Guest in The Guardian. "Fry makes a convincing case for 'the urgent need for algorithmic regulation', and wants the public to understand the compromises we are making. And, in the case of Facebook and users’ data, 'how cheaply we were bought'. This book illustrates why good science writers are essential. 'We have a tendency to overtrust anything we don’t understand,' Fry says. And if we don’t understand it, those difficult questions will be answered by those who do – pharmaceutical companies, malign governments and the like. It’s time to pull back the curtain on the algorithms that shape our lives. Because, as Fry says, 'the future doesn’t just happen. We create it.'"

Britain’s story of empire is based on myth. We need to know the truth – article by Privamvada Gopal in The Guardian. "These days we’ve become wearily accustomed to depictions of Brexit Britain as oppressed by a villainously imperial Europe.... In a particularly far-fetched comparison, Ann Widdecombe MEP has compared Brexit with the resistance of 'slaves against their owners' and 'colonies against empires'. Prime ministerial frontrunner Boris Johnson too has spoken of Britain’s supposed 'colony status' in the EU though, with a familiar double standard, he also believes that it would be good if Britain was still 'in charge' of Africa. These bizarre comparisons can be made and go unchallenged because the stark fact remains that most Britons know very little about the history of the empire itself, still less the way in which its long afterlife profoundly shapes both Britain and the wider world today. This great amnesia or 'shocking lack of understanding' has led a respected race equality thinktank, the Runnymede Trust, to call this week for the teaching of the intertwined histories of empire and migration to be made compulsory in secondary schools. Migration and empire are 'not marginal events', its report rightly notes, but 'central to our national story'."

Guy Gunaratne: ‘In London, you learn to code-switch ... I’ve always thought of that as a superpower’ – interview by Claire Armitstead in The Guardian. "A lightly fictionalised version of the murder [of off-duty soldier Lee Rigby] opens the novel, and is all the more shocking for the reaction it provokes on the street. 'The black younger had stopped soldier-boy and struck him down with a cleaver,' we are told. 'He called himself the hand of Allah but to us he looked as if he had just rolled out the same school gates as us. He had the same trainers we wore. Spoke the same road slang we used. The blood was not what shocked us. For us it was his face like a mirror, reflecting our own confused and frightened thoughts.' Most of the novel is written in a pungent first-person patois, which the author calls 'road dialect' (while conceding that it’s officially known as Multicultural London English or MLE). But this opening rings out like an omniscient chorus. So how closely does it reflect his own feelings? Gunaratne was in Finland when the news of the murder broke but watched the endlessly repeated film footage. 'The thing that shocked me was one of the killers: the way he expressed himself really did remind me of the kind of people I grew up with. There was a perverse identification which disturbed me to the extent that I knew it was something I needed to navigate for myself.'"

Literary fiction nursery rhymes – cartoon by Tom Gauld in The Guardian. "(1) Tom, Tom, the piper's son, stole a pig and away did run, but he cannot run from the traumatic relationship with his overbearing father. (2) Hickety Pickety, my black hen, she lays eggs for gentlemen, then a chance encounter leads her to ask whether there could be more to life. (3) Rub a dub dub, three men in a tub, and each, in his own way, coming to terms with loss, failure and mortality."

Margaret Hamilton: ‘They worried that the men might rebel. They didn’t’ – interview by ZoĆ« Corbyn in The Guardian. "Margaret Hamilton, [MIT] computer programmer and working mother[,] led the team that created the onboard flight software for the Apollo missions, including Apollo 11. The computer system was the most sophisticated of its day. Her rigorous approach was so successful that no software bugs were ever known to have occurred during any crewed Apollo missions... 'Often in the evening or at weekends I would bring my young daughter, Lauren, into work with me. One day, she was with me when I was doing a simulation of a mission to the moon. ... She started hitting keys and all of a sudden, the simulation started. Then she pressed other keys and the simulation crashed. She had selected a program which was supposed to be run prior to launch – when she was already “on the way” to the moon. The computer had so little space, it had wiped the navigation data taking her to the moon. I thought: my God – this could inadvertently happen in a real mission. I suggested a program change to prevent a prelaunch program being selected during flight. But the higher-ups at MIT and Nasa said the astronauts were too well trained to make such a mistake. Midcourse on the very next mission – Apollo 8 – one of the astronauts on board accidentally did exactly what Lauren had done. ... After that, they let me put the program change in, all right.'"

Listen up: why we can't get enough of audiobooks – article by Steven Poole in The Guardian. "Are audiobooks the new… books? It was recently revealed that audiobook sales rocketed by 43% in 2018, while those of print books declined (by 5%) for the first time in five years. Can people no longer be bothered to read for themselves? Is this, rather than the ebook, the harbinger of the slow death of print, about which we have been warned for so long? And if so, what does that mean for literary culture? Let us first retain some historical perspective by noting that Homer’s Iliad was essentially an audiobook before it was ever written down. Oral literary culture long precedes the book and there are many reasons for its rising popularity.... But is there really a measurable difference between reading with the eyes and “reading” with the ears? According to an oft-cited 2016 study (Beth A Rogowsky et al), 91 subjects were found to display no significant difference in either comprehension or recall after two weeks whether they had read a non‑fiction passage or listened to it, or done both simultaneously. However, this investigation used ebooks for the reading part, and other studies have suggested that reading comprehension and recall is lower for reading on screens versus print.... Books have the advantage that you can rapidly re‑scan a sentence visually if you didn’t take it in the first time... The mood in publishing seems to be that audiobooks are not cannibalising print sales to any large degree yet; more likely they are competing with podcasts, music and television as a more passive but still semi-highbrow entertainment experience."

What caused Britain’s national nervous breakdown? – article by Tim Lott in The Guardian. "When did our country lose grip of its senses? ... Researching my new novel, which focuses on the period between millennium eve and the financial crash of 2008, I was left in very little doubt about when it all started.... many of the forces I discovered were technological – but found their expression psychologically.... Most significantly there was the sudden growth of the internet, the unleashing of social media, and the accompanying change in our consciousness, which had at least as many negative effects as it had positive ones.... Instead of having a national conversation, we began to indulge in mass national bickering and mudslinging – in real time. The irony is that just as we were showing signs of collective derangement, our understanding of mental health was growing exponentially. "

The Warlow Experiment by Alix Nathan: a strange sliver of history – review by Clare Clark in The Guardian, "A few years ago, ... Alix Nathan came across a curious entry [in a 1797 reference work]. In a single short paragraph, it described what appeared to be some kind of scientific experiment, conducted by a Mr Powyss of Moreham in Lancashire. Some years earlier Mr Powyss had published an advertisement offering a reward of £50 a year for life to any man willing to live for seven years underground without seeing another human face.... His conditions would be comfortable, even luxurious: his 'commodious apartments' would include meals served from Mr Powyss’s own table, a bathtub with cold running water, a chamber-organ, and 'as many books as the occupier should desire'. According to the Register, a labouring man with a large family had accepted the post. He was, by 1797, in the 'fourth year of his probation'. Intrigued, Nathan tried to discover more about Powyss and the outcome of his experiment, but without success. Nothing of either remained. Instead she turned to fiction, writing a pair of short stories that imagined the peculiar undertaking, the first from Powyss’s point of view, 'An Experiment: Above', and then, in 'An Experiment: Below', from the solitary subterranean perspective of his confined subject. Both were included in her excellent 2014 collection, His Last Fire, which attracted acclaim from, among others, Hilary Mantel, who praised Nathan as 'an original, with a virtuoso touch'."

Pearson shifts to Netflix-style subscription model for textbooks – article by Jim Waterson in The Guardian. "[Pearson] has for years profited from the demand for specialist textbooks at US universities, which students can be required to purchase despite them sometimes costing hundreds of dollars, [but they have] been badly affected by the growth in secondhand sales and falling revenues. The company has come to accept consumer behaviour has changed and, as a result, it is shifting to a model where material is rented, not owned – similar to the change that has taken place in the music and television industry. John Fallon, the chief executive of Pearson, announced on Tuesday that the company would focus on convincing students to subscribe to access online publications. 'Our digital-first model lowers prices for students and, over time, increases our revenues,' he said.... The print editions of its 1,500 academic textbooks – which have traditionally been refreshed on a three-year cycle – will now only be updated infrequently. Students who want up-to-date teaching materials will instead have to subscribe to the electronic versions, which will be updated on a regular basis to reflect recent developments in academic fields."

Exhalation by Ted Chiang: stories from an SF master – review by Adam Roberts in The Guardian. "[Ted Chiang] has never published a novel, yet his 15 stories have won all the genre’s most prestigious awards: Hugos and Nebulas, Sturgeons, Tiptrees and BSFAs galore – more than two dozen prizes in all.... [This] collection’s two finest stories both achieve this expert balance of the emotional and the cerebral. 'The Merchant and the Alchemist’s Gate' is an intricate and delightful Arabian Nights-style yarn about a time gate; and the title story ['Exhalation'] deftly creates an alien world, bounded by solid chromium, in which live touchingly thoughtful robotic creatures. One dissects its own head in an attempt to understand how the myriad flaps of gold leaf inside its brain generate its consciousness and in doing so discovers a profound truth about the strange cosmos it inhabits. Chiang makes this entropic revelation ring like a bell, and his quaint world suddenly focuses a truth about all existence. It’s Chiang at his best, and worth the price of admission on its own."

Cressida Cowell: ‘Books are better than films at teaching children creativity and intelligence' –interview by Alison Flood in The Guardian. "When she was announced as the latest [Children's Laureate] on Tuesday, she unveiled her Laureate Charter, a 'giant to-do list' which asserts every child’s right to 'own their own book', to 'be read aloud to' and to 'see themselves reflected in a book'. ' Reading is a medium we cannot lose. I love films and telly [but] they get magically beamed into kids’ heads, whereas with books it’s much more of an effort. Books can easily represent something that makes kids feel stupid, and how can you love something that makes you feel stupid?' Her ultimate aim is to get children 'as excited about reading and books as they are about films and telly'. 'Because – I’ll just hit you with it,' she says, leaning forward in her armchair in excitement, 'because books are a kind of transformative magic that offer magical things that films aren’t as good at creating in children: empathy, creativity and intelligence. With a film, things happen out there, in a book it’s happening inside your head, so that’s empathy. Creativity – a book is partly what I say and partly what a reader imagines, whereas films are very bossy, they tell you how things would look and how they would sound. Intelligence is words. Those are the three magical powers, that’s why books have to survive – because, my goodness, we need empathetic intelligent creative people today.'"

The comma touch: Jacob Rees-Mogg's aides send language rules to staff – article by Kevin Rawlinson in The Guardian. "A list of rules has been sent to Jacob Rees-Mogg’s staff ... demanding that they use only imperial measurements and give all non-titled males the suffix Esq. ... Among the words and phrases considered unacceptable were: 'very', 'due to' and “ongoing”, as well as 'equal', 'yourself' and 'unacceptable'. Rees-Mogg’s aides also barred the use of 'lot', 'got' and 'I am pleased to learn'.... In a call for accuracy contained in his list, staff were told: 'CHECK your work.' Other directions include a call for a double space after full stops and no comma after the word 'and'.... Moreover, the phrase 'no longer fit for purpose' has been deemed no longer fit for purpose."

Jacob Rees-Mogg's language rules – cartoon by Tom Gauld in The Guardian. "Directives from the Department of Getting Back to the Good Old Days. Always commence documents with a huge letter in a decorative box. Never use the words listed in the Books of Heresy! Women to be addressed thus: Maiden, Spinster, Goodwife. Preferred units of measurement: furlong, rood, barleycorn, tod, bovate, firkin, hogshead. Ask your chaplain, steward, or local witchfinder to check your text before giving it to the Town Crier."

Friday 2 August 2019

Seen and heard: April to June 2019

First you write a sentence by Joe Moran – practical reflections on the nuts and bolts of language and how effects are created (see adapted extract). All good sense, though less impressive than I expected given the glowing review. I think I prefer Tom Gauld’s cartoon on the subject.

A House through Time – another tremendous TV series from David Olusoga, this time focusing on a house in Newcastle. Once again, a single building becomes a microcosm for the history of the city, and of Britain, with a surprising variety of occupants and uses over the years, and alarmingly abrupt changes of fortune. No doubt there were uncredited researchers who sourced a lot of the material, but Olusoga is a tremendous story-teller who gets straight to the heart of his tales. Proper history.

Reviews of Life is Strange 2 and The Walking Dead final season – the reviews, not the games themselves. Very interesting signs of how video games are growing up: in both of these games, you play a young adult looking after a smaller child, and you’re made very aware of how they’re learning behaviour and attitudes from you, so that your choices, even if they don’t massively change the storyline, play back at you later through what the child does and says. Responsible adulthood in video games? Who’d have thought it! (Postscript 12 November 2019: the video Daniel's Education Explained goes into detail about how the younger child learns from your choices in Life is Strange 2. Postscript 30 December 2019: this full review of Life is Strange 2 on Adventure Gamers relates a player's experience of the choices and the emotional impact of the game.)

The Ballad of the Judas Tree – powerful little poem by Ruth Etchells. read as part of the King's College Cambridge Easter service, and reproduced in her obituary.

Lyra McKee’s TEDx Stormont Women talk and her ‘A Letter to my 14-year-old Self’ – excerpted on Channel 4 News after her shooting during Northern Ireland protests. Compassionate and outspoken, and a lesson to us all.

Victoria – ballet by Northern Ballet. Not stunning like some of their productions, but no Northern Ballet show is ever money wasted. A nice conception: Victoria’s youngest daughter Beatrice reads her mother’s journals after her death, and sees the queen’s past life in flashback. The most emotionally powerful parts were where she enters the scene that she’s seeing: trying to tear her mother and John Brown apart, or clinging to her younger self and her future husband (now dead) as they share their first embrace.

Alastair Campbell: Depression and Me – surprisingly moving TV documentary, with Campbell’s video diaries for the programme revealing a side to him far removed from his public image.

Deep Space Nine: What We Left Behind – Deep Space Nine was the unpopular middle child of the Star Trek franchise, despised and rejected by many Trekkies, but it was always my favourite, as the most grown-up and complex of the shows, without the sunny optimism which characterised most of the others. This celebratory 25th anniversary documentary, which I helped crowdfund, not only does the usual interviews with the cast and producers, but reunites the writing team to plan out an opening episode of an imagined eighth season – and it’s a blinder. Oh what we left behind!

Telling True Stories – collection of teaching stories and sound advice from Harvard’s Nieman Conference on Narrative Journalism, by the best in the business. Some of it is narrowly journalism-focused, but much of it applies to non-fiction writing of any kind. Much cheaper than going to journalism school.

Firewatchwell-reviewed adventure game, essentially a “walking simulator” with the neat USP that you’re walking in a US National park, because your character has taken a summer job as a firewatcher and the storyline sends him all over the terrain to investigate this, that and the other. Or – as I did – you can just walk around and admire the varied and stunning scenery, without breaking a sweat.

Summer of Rockets – this year’s Stephen Poliakoff drama, and a beauty too: striking characters and vivid locations, with distinctive period features (it’s set in 1958) and neat recurring themes (secrets kept and revealed, searching for a lost loved one). The plot constantly moves on and keeps you watching, even as it meanders to the point where you wonder whether all the storylines can possibly be resolved – and then they are. Poliakoff’s father – an engineer and manufacturer of hearing aids, like the lead character – would have been very proud.

Gentleman Jack – costume romp inspired by the diaries of celebrated 18th century lesbian Anne Lister. I’d love to know just how much was historical and how much was invented, but certainly Sally Wainwright gave us a cracking story which Suranne Jones and a stellar cast realised with wit and style. The earwormingly catchy faux folk title music, though surely historically inappropriate for someone of Lister’s social class, precisely set the tone, capturing her jaunty swagger. I know some people thought there was too much about the coal-mining, but I think it was important: we needed to see Lister cutting a dash in business and estate management, otherwise it would just have been lesbian Jane Austen.

Burghley House – a lovely day out with the grandchildren, the elder fascinated by the opulence of the house, which she conceded was “cool”, the younger by the mirrors and water jets of the Garden of Surprises.

A History of Music and Technology – excellent BBC / OU radio co-production, with great archive recordings and great insights in each episode. My most important take-away: that when recording technology was first developed many musicians either couldn’t cope with the demands of recreating their performance in a studio or maintained that recorded music could never replace the live connection between performer and audience – very real issues which parallel those I continue to encounter when getting university teachers to write online distance learning materials.

Arrival / The Story of Your Life – Watching the film again on TV prompted me to read the short story on which it's based, in which the main theme – the alien writing system in which all parts of a sentence are written simultaneously, through which the protagonist comes to perceive past present and future all together – is much clearer, shorn of the thriller-like elements necessary for a Hollywood movie. The short story also contains the powerful metaphor, not in the film, of the principle of least time: a refracting beam of light travels along the path which minimises the time to its destination, which on a cause-and-effect view makes no sense because the light can’t have advance knowledge of where it’s going to end up. The film is much more comprehensible on second viewing, when you know that what you first think are flashbacks (to the protagonist’s daughter growing up and dying of a congenital illness) are in fact flashforwards, but the story is much better in taking one some way towards acquiring that simultaneity perspective oneself and much clearer about what you have to abandon: “What made it possible for me to exercise freedom of choice also made it impossible for me to know the future. Conversely, now that I know the future, I would never act contrary to that future, including telling others what I know.” I seem to be encountering references to this kind of time-collapsed vision a lot right now; it’s either a sign of wisdom, or just of getting old.

Heaven’s Vault – ground-breaking game from Inkle Studios, who also produced the excellent 80 Days. It’s an archaeology simulator which has actually won the approval of archaeologists. as well as great reviews from gamers (see Adventure Gamers and The Guardian). You play Alisa, who with her risk-averse robot companion searches for artefacts and deciphers inscriptions across a fantasy universe of river-connected moons. There’s an overall investigation plotline which advances slowly, though you have a great deal of choice in which sub-investigations you pursue and how, so the situations and dialogues are highly responsive. Overall I think I prefer more tightly structured narratives – I find Heaven’s Vault intriguing rather than compelling – but I’ll definitely play it through to the end. Blow me down, though, if there isn’t a cyclical time theme to the game: most of the inhabitants of this universe believe in The Loop – that everything that has happened will happen again – and although Alisa is sceptical we can anticipate that her character arc will have come to appreciate The Loop by the end of the game. (Postscript: see this discussion of the "end" – or is it? – and replayability of Heaven's Vault.)

The Tower of Babylon – And then I start to read another short story by Ted Chiang, who wrote ‘Story of your life’, and find that it’s about the vault of heaven. It’s a closely realised imagination of the building of the Tower of Babel, or Babylon, with detailed discussion of the engineering problems – for example how their construction techniques had to be modified when building past the orbits of the moon and sun. The protagonist is one of a team of miners who ascend the tower as it nears heaven’s vault, in order to tunnel into the firmament. He nearly drowns, when they break through into the waters above the firmament, and then emerges ...  on the surface of the earth, not far from the base of the tower. So the universe is a loop. (There's that loop again, this time in space, not in time. What's going on?)